[QUOTE=Hendrik;1065865]Same with any art which passed in a long time,
150 years after Yik Kam , lots of indepth things are distorted, lots of things are lost reference to the kuen kuit that is a fact. either one face it and reconstruct it to get back the essense or one keep on thinking one is right but ignore the distortion. [/QUOTE]
That sucks you think ‘your’ WC can’t even be passed along and gets so distorted in such a short period of time. But just because it’s true for you doesn’t mean it’s true for everyone.
And sure, people can change things along the way. But then, you are really kidding yourself if you think you can see what you have today, and also what you ‘think’ was there 150 years ago and then think you can actually know what has changed. How do you know things got distorted since then? Do you have a time machine or crystal ball to see into the past?
No, you don’t. That’s your ego showing.
So, you are just taking what WC you ‘have’, finding holes (distortions) in it and trying to plug those holes with whatever you can. And that’s cool that you are trying to fix what you think is broken. But chances are, those holes may have always been there and aren’t really ‘distortions along the way’ as you are guessing.
[QUOTE=Hendrik;1065865]in every generation there are reconstruct or rework needed because no sifu is perfect and no sifu knows it all. So there always room needed for repair/reconstruct. and it happen in any art and any lineage if the art or lineage is an alive one. That is just a part of evolution. [/QUOTE]
You are talking personal interpretation or style. That isn’t the system itself, that’s just one’s expression or take on things. And yes, some sifu can screw things up along the way, which sounds like what happened to your WC before you learned it (or maybe you’re the sifu messing it up?). But from my experience the WC system can be passed down from generation to the next intact. Or, as you’re experiencing, it can get muddled along the way. I don’t deny what you are saying as valid from your POV, but don’t project it onto everyone else. You only know what you know. Unless that crystal ball of yours lets you know what everyone in the world is doing?
[QUOTE=Hendrik;1065865]There is no such thing as I do it as what my sifu and his sifu and his sifu’s sifu did and that its. it is can one get the result as what the writing says disregards of what my sifu and his sifu and his sifu’s sifu’s did. if not, then go back to scratch board and research until the day you could get the result.[/QUOTE]
I hope you are not saying you just finally figured out that you actually have to put int he work, build the skill and prove things to yourself? This has nothing to do with ‘what sifu says’. Kung fu is about getting the skill/results thru hard work. This is nothing new. I would agree not everyone who signs up at the local mcdojo understands this, but most genuine martial artists get this pretty quickly and early on.
[QUOTE=Hendrik;1065865]1, who care what is a lineage holder title means? I dont. and title or label doesnt mean anything in the context of can one activate the engine of the art.
2, Your thinking is true for tribal logic which assume the chief of the tribe always = GOD and everything is linear. In the real world, that is not going to happen. after the second generation of the inventor. any art after the second generation evolution things will be distorted or lost when time passed. that is reality.
3, One cant learn kung fu from a book but a kuen kuit when understood precisely can lead one to advance kung fu beyond’s one’s kung fu. Refer to a Kuen kuit is not about dont know the system instead it is about making the system alive and refinement. [/QUOTE]
Hahaha, nice try dude. But don’t act like you know me and how I think - you don’t.
But I do know something about you from your writings today: you are digging into your art, finding there are things you think are ‘distorted’ or ‘missing’ and trying to ‘figure things out’ by reading some old texts. Hahaha, that’s not how things are done!
You always say one should baisi to get the real transmission and all, which is sound advice, so what happened to you?? Why didn’t this work for you? Today it sounds like you’ve baisi’d to a scroll! Maybe that’s why! lol
Here’s what is most likely the case: What you think are distortions might really just be how things were passed down from YK. Maybe what you think he got in his WC training wasn’t really the case. Maybe he didn’t complete his training (that’s why only has SLT), then went and mixed in some other arts and called it good. And it sounds like you are finally starting to see this and doing the same yourself.
Or maybe it’s just your sifu either didn’t understand the art himself.
Or hey, here’s an idea, maybe you just weren’t as good a student as you thought! 
But, I do give you credit for not just being happy with what you have when you start seeing there’s some stuff that isn’t there and trying to better yourself. But stop projecting that onto everyone else - not everyone has the misfortunes you’ve had.
[QUOTE=Hendrik;1065865]Welcome to the real world instead of simplified tribal type of world as in the Shaw’s brother Kung fu movies, “this is not Kansas any more TOTO.” as it says in Alice in the wonder land.
I would love to live in a world like what you think too.[/QUOTE]
hahaha, now that’s funny sh!t right there. Hendrik from the Lost Planet trying to welcome me to ‘his world’. No thanks, I want no part of your fantasy Island mumbo jumbo.