Wingchunners and non wingchunners!

Wai Jia: The Kung Fu Forum Wing Chun
1

I thought it would be a nice title for a new thread!..:wink:

2

:smiley:

Regards,

  • kj
3

Well we need a definition first before we can allow members to join either camp. That’s definitely a good challenge. A member will have to define what it is they do and how often they do it and against or with who. A special committee of 108 elected members can determine who qualifies for which camp.

4

i’m in the free from wing chun camp if i must be labeled :stuck_out_tongue:

5

Originally posted by Ernie
i’m in the free from wing chun camp if i must be labeled :stuck_out_tongue:

You can’t do that. There’s only two choices, wingchunner or non-wingchunner.

Ray

6

looks like i’m yet the odd ball once again :slight_smile:

7

Wing chun is terrible. Count me out.

I am a mma non fighter. OOps I have to go back to staring at walls to figure out selfhood.

Back to the cave.

8

wing chunner sounds gay
sounds to much like 4 runner

i consider myself more of a path finder

insert drum roll here -----

9

Being a “pathfinder” is a great thing.It is about being free but what about all the ones who will soon be following your new path?..They will not be as free as the finder of the path!..It will be the JKD syndrome all over again!..Oh no!..:eek: :smiley:

10

Originally posted by old jong
Being a “pathfinder” is a great thing.It is about being free but what about all the ones who will soon be following your new path?..They will not be as free as the finder of the path!..It will be the JKD syndrome all over again!..Oh no!..:eek: :smiley:

as long as you make clear each person must make there own way , and all you can do is guide from your own perspective then all will be well

you can say the jkd syndrome is also the wing chun syndrome as you are following the path of others before you and look what that is creating

nothing but seperation and my way is better then your way blah blah
good wing chun , bad wing chun and everybody thinks they have the good stuff

an endless story

11

Ernie! Don’t be so **** serious!..What have you done in Hawaii?..Some prison times?..:wink:

12

I was thinking about a secondary question in this thread…Do Winchunners enjoy sex more than non wingchunners and why do they?..:slight_smile:

13

Originally posted by old jong
Ernie! Don’t be so **** serious!..What have you done in Hawaii?..Some prison times?..:wink:

sorry bro
just have a very calm clear mind right now didn’t mean to come off all dali lama :slight_smile:

don’t worry this state will wear off soon . some of my privates are calling me and still want to train tonight in the rain , this will be a long night :smiley:

for them :smiley:

14

Originally posted by old jong
I was thinking about a secondary question in this thread…Do Winchunners enjoy sex more than non wingchunners and why do they?..:slight_smile:

they don’t there to fixed and traditional

lack creativity and can’t get the curves right :cool: :eek:

15

So you’re not …“traditional”?..:slight_smile: I hope you wear protective gear?..:wink:

Who else is not traditional?.. KJ?..Joy?..Ray?..:cool:

16

Do you think the “hip tucking” of YGKYM is an advantage over non wingchunners?..Whatever the traditional aspect?..:wink:

17

Jong asks:Who else is not traditional?.. KJ?..Joy?..Ray?..

(((Yes-I am a proper pelvic structure person in the ygkym—the resultant “rooting” is important- and as the Aussies know rooting can have a double meaning. Chinese is not the only language with a flar for double meanings))

Comments on Ernie : as long as you make clear each person must make there own way , and all you can do is guide from your own perspective then all will be well

((Individuality is important in wing chun-it is the original intercepting fist- but not the modern jkd. I agree with Ernie is on
individuation- everyone’s poetry will be their own- but ( a possible difference) you have to know the essentials of the language and its structural characteristics reflexively- rather than reinventing the wheel and going back to me Tarzan you Jane))

you can say the jkd syndrome is also the wing chun syndrome as you are following the path of others before you and look what that is creating

((Following the path is not creating it. A bit of sampling and making up a stew without knowing the ingredients is part of the problem))

nothing but seperation and my way is better then your way blah blah
good wing chun , bad wing chun and everybody thinks they have the good stuff

((An overgeneralization- in the midst of noise good things acn exist and emerge. That is partly yje plum flower and lotus metaphors))

18

Originally posted by Vajramusti
Jong asks:Who else is not traditional?.. KJ?..Joy?..Ray?..
((Individuality is important in wing chun-it is the original intercepting fist- but not the modern jkd. I agree with Ernie is on
individuation- everyone’s poetry will be their own- but ( a possible difference) you have to know the essentials of the language and its structural characteristics reflexively- rather than reinventing the wheel and going back to me Tarzan you Jane))
))

basics are basics , the human body is the same , so understanding these basic is the foundation i agree most JKD guys i have come across - though much more effective street fighters hands down , do not have the basics that are part of wing chun , but they make up for it in training and application under pressure as well as being in shape , i have trained with some that have a very deep understanding of the body and how to use it but most are just a mix of boxing, thai and bjj , still a very effective blend , since they train hard .

but your right joy once you understand your body and wing chun training gives you a way to unlock the bodies potential , then you can play your own tune

19

Many ways to self defense or fighting. Wing chun is not the only way. Better to have a super teacher in some other system than a bad wing chun teacher.

But wing chun does have some unique requirements- that does not stifle individuality. Those who studied with IM for a significant amount time have their own personalities and differences in the details of their individual applications…Leung Shun, WSL, TST, HKM etc.

Gotta go teach some wing chun.
or Jim R’s- gotta run.!!

20

Originally posted by Ernie

I was thinking about a secondary question in this thread…Do Winchunners enjoy sex more than non wingchunners and why do they?.. oj

[B]they don’t there to fixed and traditional

lack creativity and can’t get the curves right :cool: :eek: [/B]

OJ’s question was do they enjoy sex more than non-WCers.

Just because they may not be good at it doesn’t mean they don’t enjoy it more. :wink:

Why they might enjoy it more is speculative at best and hard to prove.

WC is considered a soft style…is that a +/- ???

:smiley: :smiley: :smiley: