Shaolin vs. Muay Thai

They should take up the challenge. They could win if they fight sanda rules. They’ll lose if they fight Muay Thai, but then anyone would. :rolleyes:

Thai fighters eye Shaolin
By Wang Jingqiong (China Daily)
Updated: 2009-12-01 07:59

The Shaolin Temple may have sidestepped a challenge to Chinese kungfu, but another prominent school has stepped in to pick up the gauntlet.

Five famous professional Thai Boxers offered a challenge, claiming that they wanted to “wipe out the Shaolin Temple”.

“Shaolin kungfu is a lie by these monks to Chinese Buddhists, and Chinese kungfu is nothing compared with ours,” said one of the five Thai boxers who is ready to take on masters from the famous temple.

“If they accept our challenge, we’ll win 5 to 0.”

But Shaolin responded by saying the provocative words were “ridiculous”, refusing to reply to the “secular challenge”.

Zheng Shumin from Shaolin Temple said the temple is a holy Buddhist place where monks’ primary concern is Zen practice and they would not get into contests with secular people.

“We receive so many challenges like this every year, we just don’t want to reply,” Zheng said. “We think this is hype from the Thai boxers and the organizers of the competition.”

“In the history of Shaolin Temple, we never challenge or agree to fight others,” said Zheng.

However, followers of Emei kungfu, another important school of martial arts in China, considers this a challenge that “any kungfu practitioner with a sense of justice should face.”

Wang Jian, director of the Emei Martial Arts Association, and his senior disciple Huang Lin, entered the contest “to let the Thai boxers know that Chinese kungfu is never easy to beat.”

“I couldn’t bear it anymore … after the public and all my fellow disciples urged me to show them real Chinese kungfu,” Wang said.

“This is not only disrespectful to Chinese kungfu, it is also disrespectful to our nation,” said Zhang Ji from Emei Martial Arts Association.

“As disciples of kungfu, whether from Shaolin, Emei, Wudang, or anywhere else, we should stand up to such defiance,” he said.

The five boxers from Thailand will be in China for the contest on Dec 19 in Foshan, Guangdong province, the hometown of late action star Bruce Lee.

god i hope the kung fu boys mop the floor with mt on that day

[QUOTE=goju;973656]god i hope the kung fu boys mop the floor with mt on that day[/QUOTE]

 Those boys are just talking stuff.  They may never be seen or heard from again after this contest.  They need to toss away all the rules except that you can't deliberately kill your opponent. Mui Thai is just a funky form of kick boxing where you stand to be injured by yourself as much as by your opponent.

LCP

“In the history of Shaolin Temple, we never challenge or agree to fight others,”

BBBWAAAHAHAHAHAH !!!

Now, that was funny !!

werent the shaolin monks a bunch of bandits originally lol

I thought that Shaolin Temple had guys there that they refer to as “fighting monks”? On the other hand, I also thought not everyone who trains (trained) there was a monk. They should take up the challenge. Though I’d still bet on the Thais, esp. if they are top professionals.

Officially, it’s tough for the institution of Shaolin to accept challenges…

…But I’ve witnessed some challenge matches there firsthand. They are a little more underground, at least they used to be. The warrior monks and folk masters of Shaolin are very proud. They don’t take kindly to challengers.

It was an odd quote for Zheng Shumin to be caught - sort of a gotcha question. :stuck_out_tongue: Thai fighters frequently come to challenge Chinese fighters. Thai vs. China fights are fairly commonly staged in both countries, using either Muay Thai or Sanda rules. I’ve met a few of China’s national Muay Thai team fighters. This article feels more like a very cagey promotion for this upcoming Dec 19 fight in Foshan. It’s already spread to a few other sites on the internet. It’s got a great title for viral marketing. :wink:

Score one for me

Looks like Bojizhe and I are on the same page. Nice follow up.

Muay Thai claims to wipe out Shaolin Temple, media hype?
16:27, December 02, 2009

Five famous professional Thai Boxers offered a challenge, claiming that they wanted to “wipe out the Shaolin Temple” just before the 2009 Chinese Kung Fu vs. Professional Thai Kick-boxing Competition held Dec 19 in Foshan, Guangdong province, the hometown of late action star Bruce Lee.

“Shaolin Kung Fu is a lie by these monks to Chinese Buddhists, and Chinese Kung Fu is nothing compared with ours,” said one of the five Thai boxers.

But Shaolin responded by saying the provocative words were “ridiculous”, refusing to reply to the “secular challenge”.

Zheng Shumin from Shaolin Temple said the temple is a holy Buddhist place where monks’ primary concern is Zen practice and they would not get into contests with secular people.

“We receive so many challenges like this every year, we just don’t want to reply,” Zheng said. “We think this is hype from the Thai boxers and the organizers of the competition.”

“In the history of Shaolin Temple, we never challenge or agree to fight others,” said Zheng.

Emei director stands up in defiance

However, followers of Emei Kung Fu, another important school of martial arts in China, considered this a challenge that “any Kung Fu practitioner with a sense of justice should face.”

Wang Jian, director of the Emei Martial Arts Association, and his senior disciple Huang Lin, entered the contest “to let the Thai boxers know that Chinese Kung Fu is never easy to beat.”

“I couldn’t bear it anymore … after the public and all my fellow disciples urged me to show them real Chinese Kung Fu,” Wang said.

“This is not only disrespectful to Chinese Kung Fu, it is also disrespectful to our nation,” said Zhang Ji from Emei Martial Arts Association.

“As disciples of Kung Fu, whether from Shaolin, Emei, Wudang, or anywhere else, we should stand up to such defiance,” he said.

Netizen: it is media hype

When the challenge is hotly discussed on the Internet, a netizen named “Bojizhe” on Tianya Forum, a hot Chinese Forum, said the coverage is not true, just media hype.

The netizen said he tried to verify the report from Thailand but was told that Kaoklai, the King of Muay Thai, never receive any invitation to attend the 2009 Chinese Kung Fu vs. Professional Thai Kick-boxing Competition and never claimed that Muay Thai could wipe out Shaolin Temple.

[QUOTE=Lee Chiang Po;973658]Mui Thai is just a funky form of kick boxing where you stand to be injured by yourself as much as by your opponent.
[/QUOTE]

If you ever want some insight to the true depth of Muay Thai technique & strategy, I’m just right down the road. :slight_smile:

he does have some what of a point though

id rather learn muay thai boran its more complete of a style

Muay Thai to face “real Chinese kung fu”

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/cndy/2009-12/01/content_9082164.htm

The Shaolin Temple may have sidestepped a challenge to Chinese kungfu, but another prominent school has stepped in to pick up the gauntlet.

Five famous professional Thai Boxers offered a challenge, claiming that they wanted to “wipe out the Shaolin Temple”.

“Shaolin kungfu is a lie by these monks to Chinese Buddhists, and Chinese kungfu is nothing compared with ours,” said one of the five Thai boxers who is ready to take on masters from the famous temple.

“If they accept our challenge, we’ll win 5 to 0.”

But Shaolin responded by saying the provocative words were “ridiculous”, refusing to reply to the “secular challenge”.

Zheng Shumin from Shaolin Temple said the temple is a holy Buddhist place where monks’ primary concern is Zen practice and they would not get into contests with secular people.

“We receive so many challenges like this every year, we just don’t want to reply,” Zheng said. “We think this is hype from the Thai boxers and the organizers of the competition.”

“In the history of Shaolin Temple, we never challenge or agree to fight others,” said Zheng.

However, followers of Emei kungfu, another important school of martial arts in China, considers this a challenge that “any kungfu practitioner with a sense of justice should face.”

Wang Jian, director of the Emei Martial Arts Association, and his senior disciple Huang Lin, entered the contest “to let the Thai boxers know that Chinese kungfu is never easy to beat.”

“I couldn’t bear it anymore … after the public and all my fellow disciples urged me to show them real Chinese kungfu,” Wang said.

“This is not only disrespectful to Chinese kungfu, it is also disrespectful to our nation,” said Zhang Ji from Emei Martial Arts Association.

“As disciples of kungfu, whether from Shaolin, Emei, Wudang, or anywhere else, we should stand up to such defiance,” he said.

The five boxers from Thailand will be in China for the contest on Dec 19 in Foshan, Guangdong province, the hometown of late action star Bruce Lee.

this has already been posted bubba

Gene Ching called and said he wanted his thread back

:mad:

Oops, my bad. Been offline for awhile and didn’t catch it. :slight_smile:

I’m going to the local chapter of the knights of columbus and challenging them!

lol @ the thais for making such a ludicrous approach. They are in a monastery for pete’s sake. Go challenge one of the wu guans.

you think they would have learned after what happened with oyamas guys and lui hailong:D

the challenged parties should just set the rules as a shuai jiao competition :smiley:

[QUOTE=goju;973952]you think they would have learned after what happened with oyamas guys and lui hailong:D[/QUOTE]

Most of Oyama’s guys got their butt’s kicked the frst time around.

[QUOTE=Lucas;973954]the challenged parties should just set the rules as a shuai jiao competition :D[/QUOTE]

no ethiopian sumo!

"Most of Oyama’s guys got their butt’s kicked the frst time around.
they did? i have been lied too!

[QUOTE=goju;973959]no ethiopian sumo!

"Most of Oyama’s guys got their butt’s kicked the frst time around.
they did? i have been lied too![/QUOTE]

I am pretty sure, of course there were a few trips to Thailand and they did start winning after that first one, because Oyama adopted the MT training methods, prompting some to call Kyokushin “MT with a Gi”.