Good Traditional Kung Fu

[QUOTE=bawang;979178]i have a serious question
rockets and cannons have been in china for 1000 thousand years
why dont traditional chinese martial art schools teach them?
has any civilian chinese martial arts ever taught ancient , not modern firearms? or bows and arrow?

does chinese civilian martial arts have anything to do with the chinese military at all? were they similar at all?[/QUOTE]

I don’t know.. but your rocket launcher video is a sign from the Celestial Emperor that I need to develop my bagua shotgun techniques to a high level!

Also the two of you need to get a room!

[QUOTE=dimethylsea;979193]
Also the two of you need to get a room![/QUOTE]i don’t play well with midgets. :smiley:

[QUOTE=bawang;979178]i have a serious question
rockets and cannons have been in china for 1000 thousand years
why dont traditional chinese martial art schools teach them?
has any civilian chinese martial arts ever taught ancient , not modern firearms? or bows and arrow?

does chinese civilian martial arts have anything to do with the chinese military at all? were they similar at all?[/QUOTE]

I don’t know about China, but we drill weapons training all the time. Washer techniques to train trigger squeeze, box methods for acquiring targets, firing rates, fundamentals, advanced rifle marksmanship, lane drills, etc etc etc. Gets even more complicated once you get into into arty and armor.

Most people don’t realize that if you aren’t trained with a gun, odds are you won’t hit anything you are shooting at. Better off using it as a club, really.

[QUOTE=Drake;979198]Most people don’t realize that if you aren’t trained with a gun, odds are you won’t hit anything you are shooting at.[/QUOTE]that’s the beauty of a 12 gauge semi auto with buckshot… just point and shoot, you’ll hit something. :slight_smile:

[QUOTE=uki;979212]that’s the beauty of a 12 gauge semi auto with buckshot… just point and shoot, you’ll hit something. :)[/QUOTE]

At point blank range, maybe. How do you think you’ll do at 300m? Irritate, anger your opponent, maybe?

I just did some research, and apparently buckshot begins to lose efficiency, or at least shot group tightness, at around the 20 yard mark. Also, the problem with any long barrelled weapon when used, say, indoors, is the prospect of having your barrel grabbed by the enemy. I haven’t seen this used in actual combat, but I have heard that it got a couple of people killed, plus I have seen it used during actual MOUT site training, where our OPFOR grabbed the barrel of an M4 as they were room clearing, and the other “insurgent” shot the person.

During OCS we were also taught to use the muzzle of the weapon as a spear, working as a very painful nonlethal method of subduing folks. I dunno about that, though…

I admire that the teacher in the clip actually spars and and his students spar with him.. but his traditional kung fu is questionable. His 2 forms he demos for Wing Chun (in other clips) are clearly influenced by 2 different and distinct lineages both of wich have made numerous books and videos for sale. I would have to be very suspicous that his Sifu was a VCR!!! Having said that he still might have good skills and even be a good teacher, just not one of traditional kung fu.

[QUOTE=Drake;979232]At point blank range, maybe. How do you think you’ll do at 300m? Irritate, anger your opponent, maybe?[/quote]well then my rifle skills will kick in. :slight_smile:

I just did some research, and apparently buckshot begins to lose efficiency, or at least shot group tightness, at around the 20 yard mark.
exactly… 00 buckshot is at .33 and 000 is at .36 - so you have either 9 .33 shot flying at you or you have 8 .36 shot flying at you… it doesn’t matter about aim at this point.

Also, the problem with any long barrelled weapon when used, say, indoors, is the prospect of having your barrel grabbed by the enemy.
woopie-****ing do, then i will headbutt their punk a$$ or something similar… don’t toy with the subject here. :stuck_out_tongue:

I haven’t seen this used in actual combat, but I have heard that it got a couple of people killed, plus I have seen it used during actual MOUT site training, where our OPFOR grabbed the barrel of an M4 as they were room clearing, and the other “insurgent” shot the person.
i dunno how this turned into storming rooms with sweepers and getting killed by insurgents…

During OCS we were also taught to use the muzzle of the weapon as a spear, working as a very painful nonlethal method of subduing folks. I dunno about that, though…
stick em first with the barrel and then pull the trigger. :smiley:

[QUOTE=uki;979249]
woopie-****ing do, then i will headbutt their punk a$$ or something similar… [/QUOTE]

… :rolleyes: Or maybe you could juggle at them.

[QUOTE=Drake;979232]At point blank range, maybe. How do you think you’ll do at 300m? Irritate, anger your opponent, maybe?
[/QUOTE]

I think it’s worth mentioning that in a Western industrialized society virtually all firearms combat is at “point blank” or close range.. unless you are a professional of some kind (i.e. law enforcement, military or some sort of heavy criminal type).

That’s one reason why rapid weapon access, weapon retention, and point-shooting/indexing are the top firearm priorities for civilians in the West. Sighted longer range fire and the sorts of things Drake is talking about are primarily for war or prep for same.

If you are a professional in an action profession.. obviously your priorities are going to be very different.

Personally if I need to kill a human at 300 m. something has gone horribly horribly wrong (some sort of bizarre revenge scenario perhaps?). In a self-defense scenario if I have 300 m of distance that qualifies as a win for the good guys (run away! run away!).

[QUOTE=Kansuke;979251]Or maybe you could juggle at them.[/QUOTE]well i certainly realize i can juggle your balls just fine. :slight_smile:

[QUOTE=Kansuke;979251]… :rolleyes: Or maybe you could juggle at them.[/QUOTE]

If you saw some crazed long-haired stoneworker/hippy type walking towards you juggling grenades.. wouldn’t you run like f*ckall? I would…

Why do I even bother engaging Uki in conversation. You deviated from every single point I made, and your responses were so completely irrelavant, it destroyed the topic.

I’m not talking a drop from 9 to 8 pellets. I’m talking maybe like 2, which will only irritate the attacker. You may even get an “ouch”. As for rifle “skills”, you are only reinforcing my point that one must be trained in firearm use in order to be effective.

The grabbing of the barrel, and room clearing incidents are to reinforce the point that long barrelled weapons become a hindrance in homes, as corners can neutralize the weapon.

This is all based on Bawang’s mention that there should be a mention of firearms in martial arts, and that is absolutely true. You can’t simply purchase a gun and expect it to do the work for you. There is a degree of proficiency that must be achieved in order for any firearm to be used effectively. Consider the price of missing, ESPECIALLY when in close quarters.

[QUOTE=dimethylsea;979252]I think it’s worth mentioning that in a Western industrialized society virtually all firearms combat is at “point blank” or close range.. unless you are a professional of some kind (i.e. law enforcement, military or some sort of heavy criminal type).[/quote]drake somehow fails to see this…

That’s one reason why rapid weapon access, weapon retention, and point-shooting/indexing are the top firearm priorities for civilians in the West.
drake is not a civilian - this may explain his lack of civilian understanding on the matter.

Sighted longer range fire and the sorts of things Drake is talking about are primarily for war or prep for same.
civilians are hunters too… drake somehow thinks that only those in the military are going to be a good shot. :rolleyes:

Personally if I need to kill a human at 300 m. something has gone horribly horribly wrong (some sort of bizarre revenge scenario perhaps?). In a self-defense scenario if I have 300 m of distance that qualifies as a win for the good guys (run away! run away!).
i agree, snipers are pu$$ies - gutless, spineless, cowards… death from afar… how corny can you be?? LMAO!!!

[QUOTE=Drake;979258]Why do I even bother engaging Uki in conversation. You deviated from every single point I made, and your responses were so completely irrelavant, it destroyed the topic.[/quote]only from your limited angles of perception perhaps…

I’m not talking a drop from 9 to 8 pellets. I’m talking maybe like 2, which will only irritate the attacker.
hmmmm… i dunno what kind of pellets you are talking about here… does anyone else have a shotgun that shoots harmless buckshot pellets?? anyone??

You may even get an “ouch”.
you are amazing… let me shoot you with just one buckshot “pellet” and we’ll see if you just say ouch.

As for rifle “skills”, you are only reinforcing my point that one must be trained in firearm use in order to be effective.
highly circumstancial to the type of firearm one is using. training handguns is different than let’s say a .308 or a shotgun.

The grabbing of the barrel, and room clearing incidents are to reinforce the point that long barrelled weapons become a hindrance in homes, as corners can neutralize the weapon.
this is where “martial arts” and “unarmed combat” come in, no?? and you can always saw off the shotgun barrel einstein.

This is all based on Bawang’s mention that there should be a mention of firearms in martial arts, and that is absolutely true.
LOL

You can’t simply purchase a gun and expect it to do the work for you.
at the price of guns these days, it had better work. :stuck_out_tongue:

There is a degree of proficiency that must be achieved in order for any firearm to be used effectively.
come on drake, this is america, most people were born shooting guns… heck i started when i was like 7 or something - it’s like riding a bike, you really never lose the ability once you have it.

Consider the price of missing, ESPECIALLY when in close quarters.
aim small, miss small… so what are all you army guys using in close quarters?? some kind of gun that we cannot get?? LOL… the army truly has warped your mind hasn’t it??

Grow up, Uki. You are embarassing yourself and whatever made up martial arts/juggling/insanity to which you subscribe. No wonder nobody comes here anymore.

[QUOTE=Drake;979382]Grow up, Uki. You are embarassing yourself and whatever made up martial arts/juggling/insanity to which you subscribe. [/quote]damn… i must have touched and exposed nerve. i don’t really believe that you can be all that you can be in the army - is that like false advertisement or something?? most kids join to put themselves thru school and get and education, but then they end up as cannon fodder in some accursed mountain range somewhere because americans are too pathetically apathetical to put a stop to all this nonsense being carried out by a bunch of goons in suits that have somehow duped the american population into thinking that they represent the interests of the common man in this country(aka president/current american government)… you better grow up drake. open your eyes to all the bullsh!t going on around you. sending our men and women off to fight wars perpetuated by some bloodsucking corporate entities and a lobbied political community is asinine to say the least… more than ever we need american soliders on american soil… while your lot is off fighting the ghost terrorists somewhere, the real terrorists will destroy our country from the inside out and LEGALLY.

No wonder nobody comes here anymore.
that’s odd, i have been recieving more than my fair share of private messages these days. :slight_smile:

say that to the people at your local bar who beat you to a bloody pulp
rorflll

who likes the idea of adding modern firearms to traditional kung fu? firearms in ancient china seemed to have mystical and mebbe sacred powers. i think this day and age the only way to move on is to learn from modern tiems

since kung fu loves forms so much why not make a gun form? do a kung fu salute with a gun then do some basic drawing and shooting postions. it wud be badass
bagua circle walking with a riot shield and shotgun :eek: why not

i like us army its the most advanced army inthe world with incredib le technology. if americans love their country they would be unstoppable

have you seen that movie staring batman: equalibriam? (sp) its got a ‘gun kata’ in it. neat and silly at the same time. supposedly based off of angles and high percentage reaction blah blah blah blah…

noe

im saying a few basic army rifle drills with a kung fu salute in the beginning and the end is a better step in teh rite direction than researching “how to defeat the deadly ju jitsu”

i think a lot of instructors could get good use out of things like this:

modern cqb tactics.

http://www.tactical-life.com/online/tactical-weapons/cqb-assault-rifle-defense/

also:

PLA bayonet drill: IE: Rifle kungfu form/drills/sparring

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MqBDbCR2gww