I mean of course you have raising knee to maintain the centerline when a opponent attacks or kicks. You lift the knee up to cover your vital areas. But can Lifting knee be also utilize as an attack?
In my WC every attack is a defense and every defense is an attack…
108 knee strikes. Theres a knee dummy and kneeling pole form along with fighting on your knees if you get cut in the knife form.
Oh and chi-knee, extensively done in private lessons with, ykw…
I perfer flying knees. Knees to kevin forehead…an retreating knee, knee to chin technique…
[QUOTE=k gledhill;1163589]108 knee strikes. Theres a knee dummy and kneeling pole form along with fighting on your knees if you get cut in the knife form.
Oh and chi-knee, extensively done in private lessons with, ykw…[/QUOTE]
Yep, we hit with the knee… it can be very practical, but it’s not any kind of special technique. Just think about the old saying, “every kick is a step and every step is a kick”. At the right range, the same is true of the knee. Move like a WC man and you will step, kick and knee your opponent without even thinking about it.
Yep, we hit with the knee… it can be very practical, but it’s not any kind of special technique.
I think that line sums up the WC approach to knees pretty well.
From what ive seen most WC folks will use a knee when opportunity arises (such as a lot of demo clips that finish with a killer knee once the opponent has been overcome), but im yet to see what id call a systematic approach to knees in comparison to say MT
Theres a BIG difference to a knee and a proper structured knee strike
[QUOTE=Yoshiyahu;1163597]I perfer flying knees. Knees to kevin forehead…an retreating knee, knee to chin technique…[/QUOTE]
Ah but I have iron forehead, honed with sticky head-guek [ no r ] A technique from a liverpudlian lineage of VT .
Seriously , I kneed a guy in a fight outside a bar. There was 2 of us versus 4-5? of them on a binge drink. I was going to throw a guy out of a bar for being aggressive to the barmen… as he was told he had to go he went to hit my security partner. I was standing behind the guy trying to hit him, in packed 7 deep bar, So we didnt have too many options…
As he pulled back to swing at my partner, I grabbed his jacket collar and dragged him just enough backwards so he didnt fall over but couldn’t fight back.
We ended up outside in the street , he started wrestling my partner and they both fell into the gutter, wrestling …:rolleyes: [ ground fighting is bad when you need help ]
So my manageress joins in and as she is trying to help pull them apart on the ground a second party-goer steps up and pulls her off, she screams, all hell breaks loose.
As I am pulling the wrestlers apart another 3rd party-guy goes to hit me from my left so I knocked him out with a turning facing punch to his nose.
As I finished hitting the guy, the 2nd guy who pulled the manageress off, grabbed my jacket and pulled me over the two on the ground, still wrestling :rolleyes:…
So he pulls my jacket and it ends up over my head, so I KNEED him hard in the stomach unable to hit him and he fell back with my jacket..I followed seamlessly into a low kick to his party pieces as he went backwards. After that he decided he had enough .
So there I kneed ! I felt dirty afterward, like I was unclean for using a knee, Luckily nobody from class saw me..
[QUOTE=GlennR;1163604]I think that line sums up the WC approach to knees pretty well.
From what ive seen most WC folks will use a knee when opportunity arises (such as a lot of demo clips that finish with a killer knee once the opponent has been overcome), but im yet to see what id call a systematic approach to knees in comparison to say MT
Theres a BIG difference to a knee and a proper structured knee strike[/QUOTE]
If by “proper structured knee strike” you mean the kind of specific and very committed knee training you see in Muay Thai, I have to agree. First, WC avoids that kind of total commitment to strikes …we don’t want to compromise our structure and give our opponent something to use against us.
Secondly, the simple, straightforward way we use our knees is part and parcel of the way we step and move. It integrates seamlessly with the stance, steps, and kicks so whether you just step in, kick, or knee is simply a matter of the openings your opponent gives you …it is all an expression of the same forward intent. I often disagree with Kevin on particulars, but the line in his signature really says it all: It is your opponent who will teach you how to hit him.
[QUOTE=Yoshiyahu;1163585]Does Wing Chun have knee Strikes?
I mean of course you have raising knee to maintain the centerline when a opponent attacks or kicks. You lift the knee up to cover your vital areas. But can Lifting knee be also utilize as an attack?
In my WC every attack is a defense and every defense is an attack…[/QUOTE]
Knee to the thigh or knee to the (side) of knee - they hurt like hell. IMO I would say yes because you can use the knees to fight with. Knee to the head or to the ribs I would say no unless the person was falling or on the ground and then you catch the opponent with a knee.
It can be summed up this way:
Do forms represent every technique/the core techniques in a style?
If no forms from a system have a particular technique, does that mean that technique is NOT part of the system?
In traditional Karate there were no round kicks ( mawashi geri / roundhouse kicks) and you will NOT find one in any of the original forms (katas) of any Okinawan system.
Yet they added the kick later one because it was a very good technique.
They didn’t add it to any of the forms however.
Yet ALL styles of Karate now have the roundhouse kick as part of their basic curriculum.
But there is no arguing that it was added later on.
The thread imo illustrates a common confusion…of folks assuming that ther wing chun represents all wing chun.
More accurate to say-- my wing chun has this or my wing chun does not have this and give possible reasons for the presence or absence of x, y or z..
In the wing chun that i do training the knees is very important and knees can be used for various purposes including strikes- the mechanics are different from muay thai.
[QUOTE=Vajramusti;1163840]The thread imo illustrates a common confusion…of folks assuming that ther wing chun represents all wing chun.
More accurate to say-- my wing chun has this or my wing chun does not have this and give possible reasons for the presence or absence of x, y or z..
In the wing chun that i do training the knees is very important and knees can be used for various purposes including strikes- the mechanics are different from muay thai.
joy chaudhuri[/QUOTE]
Can you give me an application of how you’d use a knee Joy?
If by “proper structured knee strike” you mean the kind of specific and very committed knee training you see in Muay Thai, I have to agree. First, WC avoids that kind of total commitment to strikes …we don’t want to compromise our structure and give our opponent something to use against us.
Not all knee strikes in MT are very committed, as you put it, and as they constqantly train the knee to strike they dont really compromise their structure as much as youd think
Secondly, the simple, straightforward way we use our knees is part and parcel of the way we step and move. It integrates seamlessly with the stance, steps, and kicks so whether you just step in, kick, or knee is simply a matter of the openings your opponent gives you …it is all an expression of the same forward intent. I often disagree with Kevin on particulars, but the line in his signature really says it all: [I]It is your opponent who will teach you how to hit him.
Thats easy to say, another thing to do. Are you just going to pull a knee out of the hat as youre marching into him??
Personally, i think everyone sells short the proper technique and associated practice that is required for effective use of the knees.
Its like saying im a wrestler but as im going forward ill pull out a perfect WC straight punch, even though i dont practice it.
[QUOTE=GlennR;1163879]Can you give me an application of how you’d use a knee Joy?[/QUOTE]
Glenn-Good faith sharing answers to good faith questions. I assume you are referring to an application or applications. Application requires development first.Development comes from doing the forms well and doing the relevant drills well and purposefully.
1.For development the forms that I do- empty hand, dummy, and weapons all have motions for knee development. In the dummy alone- there are movements where a lifting knee or footwork knees are involved. A knee can go up. dip down, go right or go left. Power comes from the main axis and the motion however slight of the standing leg. Wing chun knee work is very very close quarters work.
On applications- applications depend on the structural inter-relationships of you and your opponent(s). In certain situations if you have not completely moved in you can jam someone’s kick BEFORE it picks up full power. If you have some control over the opponent’s structure via the head, neck, shoulder, elbow or hand level, you can knee- gut, groin,or head- if he is bending down. You can knee someone’s thigh from 4 directions. If you are close but to the side of the opponent and you have both hands at work you can knee a kidney. Many other applications are possible in different situations when practice has been regular.. Proper distance and balance are important keys- not memorized techniques and time wasted on decision making.Hands and legs work together.
I was taught that a knee kick was just a short legged kick. Every point of your body that can be used defensively or offensively is a weapon. I always liked to kick because it was many times more powerful than the hand. I can kick in really tight situations, but there is a limit, and when that happens you shorten the kicking weapon by using the knee. If you can get any part of the upper body close enough you can kick it or slam it with a knee. The knee is like an elbow. It is not as proficient as a fist or foot, but it can be used with good effect if it is what you have. You can hold on to someone and still pound him in the head with an elbow. The knee or elbow is simply not a primary weapon and any techniques that apply it like a primary weapon is a waste. It is a secondary weapon that is applied when nothing else is workable or if an opportunity actually presents itself.
Glenn-Good faith sharing answers to good faith questions. I assume you are referring to an application or applications. Application requires development first.Development comes from doing the forms well and doing the relevant drills well and purposefully.
Thanks for that Joy. But id ask, where is the knees in the form and what drills do you folks do
1.For development the forms that I do- empty hand, dummy, and weapons all have motions for knee development. In the dummy alone- there are movements where a lifting knee or footwork knees are involved. A knee can go up. dip down, go right or go left. Power comes from the main axis and the motion however slight of the standing leg. Wing chun knee work is very very close quarters work.
Could you explain foot work knees to me?
On applications- applications depend on the structural inter-relationships of you and your opponent(s). In certain situations if you have not completely moved in you can jam someone’s kick BEFORE it picks up full power. If you have some control over the opponent’s structure via the head, neck, shoulder, elbow or hand level, you can knee- gut, groin,or head- if he is bending down. You can knee someone’s thigh from 4 directions. If you are close but to the side of the opponent and you have both hands at work you can knee a kidney. Many other applications are possible in different situations when practice has been regular.. Proper distance and balance are important keys- not memorized techniques and time wasted on decision making.Hands and legs work together.
So from that id assume youre preferably looking for some kind of control before the knee is applied?