need an honest answer

[QUOTE=msg;732286]because lets face the truth its not that hard to stop a grappler. thats the real truth[/QUOTE]

I would have to disagree with you there. If you are up against a good grappler, every single time you strike you put yourself at risk from a grapple of some sort. I’m not saying grappling is better, just pointing out that it’s not easy to take anyone that is a master of their art down, regardless if it’s grappling or striking.

[QUOTE=Jingwu Man;732216]

Edit- I do know of a high level taiji master that is assembling a group of students to train for the UFC. His goal is to have a taiji only fighter win in the UFC, and if you’ve seen this guy, you can believe it’s possible.[/QUOTE]

Wow, what kind of Tai Chi master would allow his students to flaunt their skills in such a manner?

I think he is just tired of people saying that TCM can’t hold it’s own in those competitions. So he’s gonna train students to fight MMA with Taiji.

[QUOTE=Jingwu Man;732388]I think he is just tired of people saying that TCM can’t hold it’s own in those competitions. So he’s gonna train students to fight MMA with Taiji.[/QUOTE]
If this person or yourself doesn’t mind, who is he?

Banned. Nice one Gene.

[QUOTE=NJM;732374]Wow, what kind of Tai Chi master would allow his students to flaunt their skills in such a manner?[/QUOTE]

Why not?:confused:

[QUOTE=msg;732286] and all i have to say is for a real kung.fu artist would be able to beat ufc guys because lets face the truth its not that hard to stop a grappler. thats the real truth[/QUOTE]

Ah, he makes with the jokes, he does.

[QUOTE=Shaolin Wookie;732250]HAHAHAHAHAHAHA…everyone usually misses the point…

But SDiscool caught it…

Traditional (“true”) fighters do compete in the UFC and MMA tournaments. Almost every good fighter has a solid background in a traditional, non-watered down art. They study techniques of other arts to round out what their training misses out on, and to cover personal weaknesses.

But soooooo many MMA guys miss out on that point. Guys like Lidell and everone else are labeled MMA, so they say…I’ll go learn MMA. But they’re buying their tacos from Chick-Fila, and their burgers from KFC.

If you want to fine-tune your striking, study a traditional striking art. If you want to fine-tune your grappling/throwing, go study a traditional grappling/throwing art. If you want a little bit of this, and a little bit of that (which doesn’t add up to much, when the sum is laid out on the table), go to your local MMA school and get bilked out of money by jacks-of-all trades.

You rely on your strengths, and some of the best MMA fighters are far better strikers than grapplers…and they almost always studied traditional arts…

Is it a coincidence?

Plenty of the Gracies were terrible strikers in their heyday…do you think they asked other terrible strikers (grapplers) how to strike in order to round out their repertoire?

For those of us not planning to join the UFC anytime soon, we don’t really have to deal with lots of grappling or groundfighting, so we don’t necessarily train them. Kind of like taking a gun with you on a visit to the Moon…do you really need it?

Maybe, if an alien happens to come along…but that’s a battle I’m fighting in the Kung Fu Forum…props to RD.;)[/QUOTE]

Yes, now here is an argument worth listening to. I was down at the local MMA school the other day watching a class. My buddy has studied judo and aikido for many years and he practices there. There’s another friend of mine into ninjutsu (don’t laugh, he likes it so what the hell). So I asked the ninja guy after the class if this is where he learned to box (I used to box and he’s got some mad skills). He told me he trains for that at the boxing gym. Apparently the only people there who only do MMA are the people there for fitness. All the advanced people started elsewhere, and still maintain thier skills. I’ve gotta say the judo/aikido guy is scary good at grappling. I sort of felt redeemed since I’ve done judo, boxing, hsing-i and aikido.

Anyhow, I can’t think of a single pro MMA guy who hasn’t trained in multiple styles with various artists. That’s what MMA means, right? Also, apparently the whole “MMA is the best style” idea is totally foreign to these folks. These guys compete too.

look i not saying grappling is no good its just for the ring …famous words it takes to long will not work in real life .lets face it your on the streets you want to end it as fast as you can no time to play around on the ground any kind of MA was not meant to look like the movies or to stand and wait for a punch or a kick to grap

[QUOTE=msg;732442]look i not saying grappling is no good its just for the ring …famous words it takes to long will not work in real life[/QUOTE]

I really hope for your sake that you are never involved in a street fight, and especially not against anyone who has had some grappling training. As far as it not working in a “real” fight, I know better. It’s saved my butt on at least one occasion, and helped me to avoid fights that were being escalated by the other party (Drunks can be fantastic people :rolleyes: ), as a little pain compliance can “assist” them in seeing the error of their ways.

.lets face it your on the streets you want to end it as fast as you can no time to play around on the ground

Not all grappling has to take you to ground (See: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/grapple ). Grappling is not the same as groundfighting. Granted the tournaments make it appear that way (grab -> go to ground -> submit), but there is a large variety of grappling techniques that can be applied while standing, not to mention if you get pinned to a wall/table/whatever. I do agree that groundfighting is should be avoided in a street fight if at all possible just because you never know who just might come up and kick you in the back of the head.

any kind of MA was not meant to look like the movies or to stand and wait for a punch or a kick to grap

That is the point of practice, so that you can seize the opportunities as they arise, same as striking. With striking you need to learn how to get around their defense and pick points that are open to your attacks and then strike them. With grappling, you need to be able to determine if you are most likely going to be able to get that grab and apply your technique. Different focal points, but both require practice, and neither one better than the other.

Something to keep in mind is that striking and grappling both require at least one of the same things, contact. You don’t have to have super-human speed in order to get a hold of a hand/leg/arm/shirt/etc. Excluding grappling from your training is going to leave you with some severe holes in your defense.

Ban the Tard BAN THE TARD BAN THE TARD

Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard Ban The Tard

to hinokata ya i have been in street fights more than a few times and not with drunks so i know what would work . and thats the bascis all ways works the best. i said it before i wouldnt want one of his friends hitting me when iam trying to wrap him up because that would happen nine times out of ten

[QUOTE=msg;732566]to hinokata ya i have been in street fights more than a few times and not with drunks so i know what would work . and thats the bascis all ways works the best. i said it before i wouldnt want one of his friends hitting me when iam trying to wrap him up because that would happen nine times out of ten[/QUOTE]

I guess we shall have to agree to disagree, and I personally disagree with most of your post because I think that information is flat out wrong. To each his own and good luck to you in any future excurisons you may have.

[QUOTE=hinokata;732464]

…there is a large variety of grappling techniques that can be applied while standing, not to mention if you get pinned to a wall/table/whatever. I do agree that groundfighting is should be avoided in a street fight if at all possible…

…With striking you need to learn how to get around their defense and pick points that are open to your attacks and then strike them. With grappling, you need to be able to determine if you are most likely going to be able to get that grab and apply your technique…

[/QUOTE]

Well said Hinokata, well said.

I have seen enough fights to know that, people involved with the “jump up and down and punch and kick” fights usually ended up with bruises, cuts, bloody noses and usually NOT hospitalized. The most brutal ones usually involve rumbles where multiple people are involved where people are grabbed, pinned, smashed etc where grappling type of skills gives you a better chance to get out of and run.

One of the BJJ instructors where I teach can basically pick you up, turn you upside down and smash you on the ground in a split second while he remains standing. So he may take a couple of hits in the process; but one can survive hits easily, but being slammed on concrete is no fun.

Movies tend to make it looks like it is so easy to knock someone out in one hit (we’ve all seen Jet Li doing it when faced with multiple attackers), stop an attacker with one stab of the knife, or shoot someone down with one bullet. In reality it is dangerous to have such misconceptions.

So, in my opinion, it is not just “How strong is the punch” that matters. Of course a powerful punch is important, but also how safe, how likely to be countered, how easy to flow into other techniques, etc. To me, the best strike would be one that’s protective, powerful, and can be continued into a break/lock and a throw, and gives you the option to run. Sounds too good to be true? No. There are such techniques in Aikido, Tian Style Bagua and of course Tai Chi just to name a few.

Cheers,
John

Apples and oranges

[QUOTE=Jingwu Man;732216]Like Jet Li said in Fearless “The true battle is with one’s self”
I myself have no reason to enter competitions, and I guess I take after my teacher in that regard. He is probably the most dangerous person I have ever met, but he is also the nicest. He is always smiling, and will walk away rather than fight. After a certain point, you know what you are capable of, and don’t need to cross hands anymore, or avoid it to spare others injury.[/QUOTE]

Jingwu Man echoes my feelings: The most dangerous men I’ve known have been some of the nicest, and slowest to take offense/fight over ego. I practice and teach martial arts to try to be like them: in order to master my own ego and temper, and to help kids do the same. At the same time, it is good to know that street applications are there in an emergency. This is much different from sport fighting, where the object is besting someone else, and dare I say, maybe often for the purpose of feeding the ego.

One could just as easily ask why those who compete in MMA don’t compete in combat shooting, quick draw competitions, sword fighting or knife fights. Getting shot, surreptitiously stabbed or clubbed from behind will negate all one’s years of training anyway. People train according to their interests and personal goals. Nothing is completely effective in every circumstance. If an individual is measuring his manliness according to his ability to grapple then he may find himself shot, clubbed from behind or gang stomped.

MMA are duels! Duels are NOT accurate facsimiles of real life self-defense situations. That is not to negate the value of grappling skills, but the REAL world is more than the primarily grappling skills displayed in MMA duels. These are tactical wrestling exhibitions where competitors have plenty of time to wear each other down. Much of it is a chess game where competitors don’t have to worry about being stomped in the head by someone else while rolling around on the ground in an otherwise vulnerable position.

Real world duels occur mostly in school where egos and childish attitudes prevail, bar/drunk fights and some peace officer situations. These are the areas where grappling skills are beneficial. Police and Correctional Officers benefit greatly from some experience in grappling, but try taking your MMA and grappling skills to a gang shoot out and see how long you will survive.

Train according to the perceived danger you expect to encounter and your personal goals and interests. But also understand that no one can be prepared for every single possible form of attack. If one needed to take someone out permanently strategy is more than important than skill. A well devised strategic plan attacks the individual’s weakness, not his strength. Therefore you do not grapple a grappler unless you are clearly superior. Even if you did grapple a grappler it would be a waste of energy when all it takes is some poison, a club from behind, a gun etc.

Most bad guys are not interested in rolling around with you on the ground. They want what you got and they want to get away quickly, or they just want to kill you. Rolling around on the ground wastes time and energy. Any other encounter is most likely motivated by ego and/or substance abuse. A mature individual, aside from Peace Officers, Security Officers and Bouncers will seek to avoid this types of encounter.

In his younger days Rick Avery had a martial arts studio in Santa Barbara CA. It was either kempo or kenpo (I can never keep them straight). Any way, he was also a Sheriff and was known for using excessive force and generally being an a**hole. Eventually he was ambushed by some High School kids with baseball bats who were tired of his attitude. He was a trained martial artist, an officer of the law, carrying a gun, a baton and mace. They sent him to the hospital.

Everyone is vulnerable to a well thought out attack, even MMA’s! Or perhaps especially MMA’s because they spend so much time practicing skills that make them vulnerable in REAL life and death situations. Take half the time they train on the ground and devote it to developing evasion skills and gun or knife skills and the time would be better spent.

thank you scott.r brown for under standing what i was trying to say .i was not trying to say any thing negative of any art .just replying to the topic street/reality fighting .key word street.i hope i did not offend any body that ws not my intent

[QUOTE=Scott R. Brown;733975]Nothing is completely effective in every circumstance. If an individual is measuring his manliness according to his ability to grapple then he may find himself shot, clubbed from behind or gang stomped.[/QUOTE]

I believe you are missing my point altogether. I am not advocating grappling as the be-all end-all form of self defense. Nor was I saying that it should be your first form of defense, etc. What I am saying, is that neglecting an area of training such as grappling is going to leave you in a trouble spot if you get grabbed or pinned. Additionally, you can just as easily be clubbed from behind while trying to play the 100% standup game.

MMA are duels! Duels are NOT accurate facsimiles of real life self-defense situations. That is not to negate the value of grappling skills, but the REAL world is more than the primarily grappling skills displayed in MMA duels. These are tactical wrestling exhibitions where competitors have plenty of time to wear each other down. Much of it is a chess game where competitors don’t have to worry about being stomped in the head by someone else while rolling around on the ground in an otherwise vulnerable position.

Do not confuse grappling with groundfighting, as they are not one and the same. I agree 100% that it is a very bad idea to go rolling around on the ground with an opponent in a street fight. Besides all the reasons mentioned in previous posts, you never know what is on the ground, like broken glass, syringes, etc.

… but try taking your MMA and grappling skills to a gang shoot out and see how long you will survive.

I’m sorry, but this is just a VERY silly example. First of all, WHY would you be in some sort of gang shoot out to begin with? And if it’s because your part of one of the gangs, then chances are you have your own gun. Secondly, you could easily replace grappling with striking, swordsmanship, staff, whatever and still come out badly. It is somewhat like the old saying, never bring a knife to a gun fight.

Train according to the perceived danger you expect to encounter and your personal goals and interests. But also understand that no one can be prepared for every single possible form of attack.

I agree with your above statement but I would like to add that if you are strictly training for sport/comps, then yes, only do what you want to do. If you are training with self-dense in mind, IMO it is very foolish to ignore a very valid part of training, even if you don’t/can’t see the value of it. It’s in the art for a reason.

If one needed to take someone out permanently strategy is more than important than skill.

Please define permanently, because that seems to provide a one way ticket to prison.

A well devised strategic plan attacks the individual’s weakness, not his strength. Therefore you do not grapple a grappler unless you are clearly superior. Even if you did grapple a grappler it would be a waste of energy when all it takes is some poison, a club from behind, a gun etc.

You’re talking about ways that are potentially lethal, and not too mention will get you thrown in jail. Poison? Another really bad example. We were talking about self-defense, not pre-meditated murder. Using the methods you describe, yes, you defend yourself, but now you spend a nice chunk of time in jail, get a criminal record, and pretty much screw up the rest of your life.

Most bad guys are not interested in rolling around with you on the ground. They want what you got and they want to get away quickly, or they just want to kill you. Rolling around on the ground wastes time and energy. Any other encounter is most likely motivated by ego and/or substance abuse. A mature individual, aside from Peace Officers, Security Officers and Bouncers will seek to avoid this types of encounter.

One could argue that a mature individual will seek to avoid all types of street type encounters. Again, you are confusing grappling and groundfighting. I would also argue that officers/bouncers will try to avoid that encounter as well, but they may have to deal with it because of their position to protect the public.

Quote:
… but try taking your MMA and grappling skills to a gang shoot out and see how long you will survive.

I’m sorry, but this is just a VERY silly example. First of all, WHY would you be in some sort of gang shoot out to begin with?


Actually, my work teaching many gang kids has put me in this situation more than once. The reaon I’ve come out the other side? Just wasn’t a bullet with my name on it on those days. Also, have always (17 years) tried to help these kids (treat with dignity and some humility), so maybe a small measure of respect was returned to me as I know on a couple of occasions, they did not shoot at rivals who were in my proximity because I was standing there.


Quote:
MMA are duels! Duels are NOT accurate facsimiles of real life self-defense situations. That is not to negate the value of grappling skills, but the REAL world is more than the primarily grappling skills displayed in MMA duels.


Agree! And not just MMA, but all sparring–not that it doesn’t have a place, but that place is not too profitable for preparation for the street.

[QUOTE=kidswarrior;734027]Actually, my work teaching many gang kids has put me in this situation more than once. The reaon I’ve come out the other side? Just wasn’t a bullet with my name on it on those days. Also, have always (17 years) tried to help these kids (treat with dignity and some humility), so maybe a small measure of respect was returned to me as I know on a couple of occasions, they did not shoot at rivals who were in my proximity because I was standing there.[/QUOTE]

I stand corrected. I really hope you reach the majority of kids you work with. I know first hand that respect goes a VERY long ways with gang members, so you may just be right about them not shooting at rivals near you. I have found that many times people tend to forget the human aspect of gang members and automatically lump them under thug and treat them like animals. While some of them are violent by choice, many of them are “forced” into it by either peer pressure, family ties, the sense of belonging, revenge, or just hoping to increase their odds of survival. Good luck with your work.

… returning to the topic now …