Alright, I’m gonna suspend disbelief here- so it doesn’t matter that Tyler Durden is a phantom… these are all fictional characters.
That said, I can’t imagine a scenario where Tyler would win. All he has going for him is toughness and craziness. My man Bruce has all that and is a professional boxer who killed a man with his bare hands. Nuff said, Bruce wins.
If we’re talking Frank Miller’s Dark Knight, my vote goes to Batman. Otherwise, Black Mask.
Fist of Legend’s Jet Li beat like a whole school of karateka. My vote goes to him.
Chow Yun Fat would probably accidentally discover highlander’s weakness from hacking him apart many, many times. Anyway, all that “there can be only one” stuff will sound a little silly coming from a guy with no arms and legs.
It’s not really fair putting old man Kane (in legend continues he’s a senior citizen) against younger Walker. That said, the clumsy brute that Walker is, Kane would overcome him with softness and kung-fu magic (have you ever seen the show, I think he has like pyrokinesis in one of the episodes).
David Dun is only extraordinary because he’s the only superhero around. Wolverine would take him apart. Unbreakable when faced with adamantium claws - I don’t think so.
If we’re talking Chow Yun Fat’s character in Hard Boiled, it’s a tough call. Rambo would come in with an M-60, making Fat’s use of the environment to get out of the way of bullets a moot point. My vote goes to Rambo.
One at a time, Yeoh would slay the angels. All at once, I hope they’d all find some mud to wrestle in, but anyway, they’d subdue Yeoh.
The way of the samurai is in desperateness. Ten men or more cannot kill such a man. Common sense will not accomplish great things. Simply become insane and desperate. - Hagakure