[Q] SF -> why have you taken your post out?
[ANS] SF-> hi shoa,not to start any wars
-> Also, because no one wants to hear logic, they only want fantasial stories. Of course there are holes one does not have to tell all!
SF : now from what i learn is that pak mei cannot be learnt from any language apart from manderin and hakka
-> What about all those Individuals trying to learn Cantonese just to understand their arts better. Are you saying it is in vain?
SF : and you put it in cantonese.
-> Nope, I put in Englocantonese which is most common. In fact it is much easier for me to put it in Mandarin but no one would understand.
Like Shi zi quan, Chi Dian Mei Hua, Ba Gua, Shi Ba Mo Qiao, Hu Bu, Hua Bao, Jiu Bu Tui, Fei Fung Shuang Dao, Fei Fung Dan Dao, Da Che Gun, …etc.
I could put it in Hakka, Hokkien, Teo Chew, Toisan, ChongSan…as well…who cares though this isn’t language class.
Vietnam, Hong Kong, Kowloon, GuangZhou, ShanTou, Hoi Fong, Malaysia, UK, USA ..etc… all may differ. But if one style cannot keep it together then all will be lost in the world.
Oh Well,
it is irrelevant just practise and be happy.