[QUOTE=Royal Dragon;872540]Reply]
Just a collection of thoughts, and thought provoking questions:
One possibility, the Shaolin Tai tzu set comes from the Tong Bei system because Tong Bei was used extensively by the military at the time. Maybe it was a key set to the Tong Bei system Zhao and all his Generals knew through the military?
Now, we may find that the Tai tzu set, IF it originally comes from this Tong Bei line may, have been named because Zhao Kuang Yin developed it (thus adding it to the line), and OR someone close to him learned it shortly after Shaolin developed it, and it got passed on as part of that persons Tong bei. OR maybe it became a standard set taught to the early Song Military after Shaoliin developed it and it was just taught with all the Tong bei the military was doing at the time?
Would this mean it is actually a version of that time period’s Tong bei and not really a new style?
Question, did Zhao Kuang Yin know the Shaolin 32 Tai Tzu Chang Chuan set? Did Shaolin teach it to him after it was developed? OR did he maybe have a bigger hand in it’s creation than we think?
Once it was developed, who would have it been taught to?
Maybe Zhao Kuang Yin didn’t invent a style at all, and all that happened is Shaolin just recorded the same military Tong Bei style he and all his Generals did, and it just got named after him because of that?
In other words, there really is no Tai Tzu Chang Chuan at all, it’s just a variant of Tong Bei that Zhao Kuang Yin happened to know and it was prominent in the particular military he was a part of. It just got a famous name because he taught part of it to Shaolin, and later sent Generals to teach them more…so it got named after him.[/QUOTE]
Dude, you mixing up all different styles that have almost the same names.
Tong Bei Quan was developed during the early Qing Dynasty by Dong family in Shanxi / Henan area first, later reached Hebei. Dong Cheng taught many versions of this style to various people, each one is a different branch of Tong Bei Quan today, such as White Ape and Hongdong Tong Bei.
The “tong bi” that you are talking about that the military did during times that Zhao Kuan Yin was in the military didn’t have an exact name, it’s called Tong Bi today for whatever reasons. These military long fist were done back into the Tang Dynasty into the Song Dynasty.
Shaolin’s Tai Zu Chang Quan was developed by his orders, but it’s not called Tai Zu because of Zhao, Zhao was named that later, it would be Forbidden to use tai Zu as a name because it was associated with an Emperor’s name.
Shaolin called it Tai Zu because it was the foundational set, developed by order of Zhao so that Shaolin could prove if someone graduated from there or not.
Zhao sent people to Shaolin to give them their best techniques.
NO ONE outside of Shaolin during this time period was allowed to practice it or teach it.
This first set, Tai Zu Chang Quan Yi Lu was used eventually by people who learned it from somewhere no one knows, and somehow by the 1600s this set got to the Dong family and Dong Cheng taught it to Chen Wang Ting, and later Chen You Bin used it.
General Zhao that we are talking about is of Chuo Jiao Fanzi FAME, he was a general during the Tai Ping Rebellion, hundreds of years later in mid 1800s, and he fled to Hebei province from southern China.
Zhao Kuan Yin developed Lao Hong Quan. He descendants that re-located to other parts of China still do these sets. The Wencheng Quan style is one of those styles developed by his descendants.
The proof is that WenCheng was developed during the 1600s, same time as Tong Bei Quan of Dong family, and later Chen TJQ. \
If Lao Hong Quan and Tai Zu Chang Quan was not from before the Qing Dynasty, it would have been impossible for people from two different provinces living at the same time period (henan and Shandong in 1600s), but developing two styles with the same theories and many of the same movements, because both were drawing from Lao Hong Quan and Tai Zu Chang Quan.