Hi German Bai lung
Thanks for posting the clips. I encouraged you to do so eventhough you were concern about the reaction that might repeat from the German board.
I would like to share my thoughts on them with other as I have already shared with you in our emails. Hope you don’t mind.
About the first clip:
http://www.bailung.de/Mantisfight1.mov
I like this clip. You can see the disciplines of mantis. To some people, they would think there is a lot of hand slapping but the truth is both side are using the hand combinations to gain the dominant positions. There are few that landed on the sides of the faces too. You can clearly see the attempts to do Deng Ta or Deng Pu takedowns with one guy (although he ended up being thrown). Also I am impressed with the agility of these guys they are alert and get on their feet as soon as they are thrown. There are plenty of the “take treasure” type of moves, which turned into shoot in, as set ups for other moves which shows an attempt in applying the fake high hit low or vice versa type of mantis stuff. The body methods are there (ie turuing). I think the training shows here. Also it is very nice to see that Chin Na (mainly elbow lock) is being attempted but as soon as it is no go, it is changed to something else. The flow is quite wonderful. It is more fluid in this clip. Although, I think some sport people might not like this one as much. But technically, I like this one.
http://www.bailung.de/Sanda1.mov
This one is pure lovely for the energy. The kicks and sweeps are superb! The conditioning is great. Man, I should beef up the training of my students. There are plenty of fast hand actions. We can see the use of hook grab pluck type of action going on even with the groves. The format is different but it is beautifully done with mantis flavor. I think it is quality stuff that you might want to share on the site. Sport people would like this one.
Do you mind if I post these on my own forum?
These 2 clips give a good idea of the broadness of your training both for the art and for the sport. BTW, I favor no glove over gloved. It is just more possibilities.
As for critics:
Well, I think their ideas of using techniques in mantis is different. I see the mainland manits rationale more so than HK mantis rationale in the clips that you provided. In all honesty, the first clip could use a bit more Chin Na, Pai An and/or Kao Do method to give more “defination”. but that’s more easier say than done. If they can do that, well those 2 would have been the sifu long ago, right? LOL… Your job would have been done!
Anyway, don’t worry about critics. You have to know what you are doing. If no one is to believe you, you have to believe in yourself. BTW, this knowledge is handed down from your teachers. If it is good for them, it is good for you. Also people just don’t realize that different methodologies breed different Kung Fu. Clip 1 (forms and drills and all) and 2 (hit heavy bag and all) of yours shows to me that you have a versatile curriculum and that’s a great thing. More importantly, the central theme “the mantis stuff” are presented in both clips. That consistancy is IMHO most important. if we were to claim that we practice and teach mantis fighting than we should have that consistancy regardless of the chosen format for delivery be it forms, self defense, sparring, art or sport etc…
I understand and respect your wish not to show them but I would think it’s refreshing to see them.
<<<For both are students and one of them are just 4 Years learning from
me, both never did MA before, they did in my opinion their work fine.
We took the video for correcting and learning some important tactical
moves. But I always thought the clips are not that bad…>>>
They are quite top notch. You should be proud of yourself. I know how hard it is to train someone. It takes 2 to Kung Fu - teacher and student. I wish I have hard working students as yours.
Just some thoughts that I would like to share.
Mantis108
PS Taojie (stealing intercept) would be a great 2 man form for sharpening the skills in the first clip as well.