So what is the enginee of SLT? how to activate it? What is its uniqueness? How to issue power?
Some has the nail and hammer model. that is great. but then where is the hammer’s power generate from?
Some has the grounding model. That is also great. But then is this a trick of lowering the Center of Gravity for demonstrationg or can that grounding be used for adaptive dynamic situtation without preparation such as in demo and limited domain to cover?
HOw is all these link into the SLT? is it the same thing? is it a different training ?
what is the similarity or different between the wing chun way of punching the heavy bag in term of body machenics, structure, COG management, speed control…compare with the western boxing way? is that way supported in SLT? how to generate power? how to accelerate and pick up speed? How is that enginee of SLT works?
Interesting comparative question! So why don’t you sky diving first this question while waiting for other people’s comments. I provided a clip of boxing heavybag for your reference! =)
Interesting comparative question! So why don’t you sky diving first this question while waiting for other people’s comments. I provided a clip of boxing heavybag for your reference! =) [/B]
Originally posted by PaulH
[B]nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn00000000000000000000000000!!!
Don’t be shy, Hendrik! I love to hear what you think! Really! =) [/B]
It is not about a critics topic. It is about an idea sharing topic.
I love to hear from everyone. So, everyone speak up. if one is going to spend 15 mins to 45mins to 2 hours of thier life daily doing SLT. one needs to look into one’s investment.
We got to encourage people to speak up and ignore put down post.
it is very likely those who put down doesnt know themself. so focus on sharing not those critics and put down.
The way to hit a heavy if you wanted to do so is the way you would hit someone.No need to do some western boxing.The WCK engine and how you use it is defferent then Western boxing,and how they generate power.In Boxing power is generated at the shoulder and by momentum and body weight to generate power.In W.C. you don’t use your shoulder that way and power is generated by body stucture,Ging from tendon power,and also on a higher level chi.In Western Boxing they don’t have the same concepts as W.C. so how can you conpare.Western boxing is not even a martail art to begin with.It’s only a sport.
In Western Boxing they don’t have the same concepts as W.C. so how can you conpare.Western boxing is not even a martail art to begin with.It’s only a sport.
Western boxing is indeed a martial art, just not a TCMA. Nearly all boxers train far harder than the average WC student and IMO would prevail in most circumstances in a defense situation because of superior attributes and conditioning, and even perhaps superior technique.
The concepts in Jack Dempsey’s “Championship Fighting” and those used to develop the punch in TWC have a good deal of intersection. Read it (link below), educate yourself.
Get hit with either a good Wing Chun punch or a right cross, the effects will be indistinguishable for all practical purposes.
Do you do SLT? Do you use heavy bag for training? if yes, please share.
Yes and Yes. I’ll show you mine when you show me yours.
it is very likely those who put down doesnt know themself.
That’s a veiled put down, so I guess you just described yourself.
SLT to my mind is a form of positioning and accurate structure, not of power generation (except indirectly as a result of those primary aims). Power generation comes substantially from footwork and the lower body, which are not utilised to their full extent in SLT in most lineages. I know you should not be dead from the waist down in SLT, even if you don’t do it with footwork, but it alone will not get you there. We have three forms plus the dummy for good reason.
The mechanics of power generation as my academy employs them are described very well in JD’s book, which is out of print but the text can be found on http://go.to/stickgrappler.
There you go. How about making a substantive post yourself, Hendrik?
Originally posted by stonecrusher69 In W.C. you don’t use your shoulder that way and power is generated by body stucture,Ging from tendon power,and also on a higher level chi.In Western Boxing they don’t have the same concepts as W.C. so how can you conpare.Western boxing is not even a martail art to begin with.It’s only a sport.
Can you please share what is the significant about Ging from tendon and higher level chi? how is this cultivated in SLT?
How is these Ging from tendon and higher level chi measured and different from Boxing?
What is the different when the punch of a boxer and a WCner hit the heavy bag? the power is different? the penetration is different?.. the body reaction of the person is different?
Thanks
just some blue sky question. ignore it if you think that is too much a question.
Originally posted by anerlich
[B]
That’s a veiled put down, so I guess you just described yourself.
[/B]
Your subsconcious never forget about always trying to attack me, dont you?
Can you please get back to technical stuffs? otherwise, you can ignore my post right?
The mechanics of power generation as my academy employs them are described very well in JD’s book, which is out of print but the text can be found on http://go.to/stickgrappler.--------
Thanks.
but,
doesnt seem to find the related subject from the above web.
Originally posted by anerlich Nearly all boxers train far harder than the average WC student and IMO would prevail in most circumstances in a defense situation because of superior attributes and conditioning, and even perhaps superior technique.
Agreed. Pretty forms win medals, not fights. And it doesn’t matter how much you know and how good you look when you run out of steam in the first five seconds of a real conflict.
There are two kinds of WC power that I know of - sitting power and motion power. SLT trains at least sitting power structurally and mentally. From an untroubled, detached, but highly focused mind, the SLT sitting power is very grounded and stable structurally; it penetrates deeply like a needlepoint strike whenever it uses.
