There is one thing that I have noted in my mind in regards to the practice of JKD in the americas.
I find that people like it because it does away with a lot of the traditional structure of chinese martial arts teachings.
Bruce Lee was big on geting rid of the “classical mess” as he called it. Personally, I think this was due to his own ego on a lot of levels. The guy was a movie star first and was desperate for fame. He didn’t know what a gem he had in his hand and while he spent his time trying to be like McQueen and Coburn, McQueen and Coburn were wishing they could have had the chance to have the teachings from Yip Man that Lee got.
It really is a “grass is greener on the other side” scenario.
Kung Fu practice builds you up by breaking you down.
It is part of the traditional ways, to crush the ego of the student so that they will come to a clear understanding of their capabilities and more importantly their weaknesses.
The student must actively participate in this rebuilding of the self to really understand them selves. If you block the breakdown because of a sense of self that is too strong, then your cup can’t be filled, because it isn’t empty.
Don’t get me wrong, there are plenty of people out there learning and teaching that do not have an “empty cup” attitude.
But, that’s humanity for you. In the west here, where there is not much suffering for the common person, the emptying of ones cup is that much more difficult because of the paradigm we develop about ourselves in a fairly sheltered society.
when you break out of this mold, you either become a detrament vis a vis anarchistic and iconoclastic tendencies, or you become a conformist to the paradigm and wind up serving society or you simply become yourself as you truly are. THe latter of these three is the most difficult path because even when you are there, you don’t know!
Anyway, Bruce wanted to get rid of all the things “he” didn’t like about chinese martial arts and this is perpetuated in many JKD schools.
The only thing that Bruce forgot about was an old idea intrinsically connected with Martial arts practice, particularly Chinese martial arts, and that is…
“You must taste bitter, if you do not taste the bitter, you cannot truly know what is sweet.”
The bitter is more than sweat and time and effort.
It is being filled with self doubt, being rigorously drilled on a day when you don’t feel like it, taking abuse and letting it go, personality conflicts with others and handling them, dissapointment, failure and rejection, these things are needed in building character which will in turn manifest in your Kung fu ability and skills and your own sense of fairness and mercy based on your direct experience.
when you have eaten all that, you can move on and live your life with your Kung Fu.
peace