Kid: You will not find a more hard-core TCMA proponent on this list than me. Most of the MMA crew you mentioned (like Knifefighter) and I have had massive arguments from time to time because of my belief that all the techniques of MMA and several that are excluded from MMA training because of rules in structured sporting events exist within TCMA. I have argued with them that the problem is not TCMA but rather certain trainers who only worry about form and forget to instruct function or conditioning. In addition I nearly ALWAYS post OT in the header if my subject is not about Gong Fu. Look at my most two recent threads: one was on-topic (practicing in public in China) the other was off topic (trouble accessing the Google network in China). I put OT in that one. So the complaints that you have levelled about others on this forum DO NOT apply to me.
This is me telling you this. Nobody else.
1: If you want to post off-topic do everyone a favour and put off-topic in the subject header.
2: The people here are serious martial artists. Some of them are traditionalists, some are not but this forum is generally not populated by punk-ass ninja wannabees and trolls. There are other forums out there where you would fit right in much better if you are not interested in a serious and respectful discussion of martial arts. This brings me to my third suggestion:
3: Respect - get some. I don’t always agree with everyone on the list. But that doesn’t mean I go ripping on them in some thread that they have no part of. That is just not cool. Just as an example, Knifefighter and I don’t agree about much. Red 5 Angel and I don’t generally participate in the same political threads because of how strongly we disagreed. But I still have a modicum of respect for them. Knifefighter steps up in MMA tournaments and sometimes he wins. He deserves props for that. Red 5 may not agree with me about politics and he may use different styles of martial arts than me but he still is a complex person and there have been martial arts related threads where the two of us have agreed about many things. What I am saying is that even if I don’t always agree with them, even if I usually DISAGREE with them, I still have some respect for them. You generally don’t show that respect. Perhaps this is part of the reason you have recieved so little of it.
4: 52 hands of the jailbird? Come on. Next you will be spouting on about cinnabar palm and how 133t Taiji can defeat any martial art but that the masters DON’T because they are all so enlightened.
Have you read anything about the founder of Yang Taiji? The guy was a ****! He’d beat the **** out of people for looking at him crosswise; his training regimen was so ferocious that his SON ran away from home to escape it. He wasn’t an enlightened sage who was too good to fight.
There are a few taiji masters left who have preserved the martial traditions of the art and IF it is combined with an appropriate training regimen: conditioning, drills (and I DON’T just mean push hands), free sparring (again, NOT push hands alone) it can be a decent grappling art. I’ve heard enough good reviews of the combat efficacy of Xingyi that I am hoping to learn some while I am here in Shanxi, I crossed hands with a Bagua player (who also did Hung Gar, Ha Long, Western Boxing and Wing Chun) and he could hit like a ton of bricks while still being deceptive in his timing and movements. I’m not saying that there is no validity to the internal arts. I’m just saying that most SERIOUS martial artists who are interested in RBSD learn some external fighting too; it’s just smart.
Of course for every 1 martial Taiji instructor there are probably 50 who do it for the non-martial health benefits and another 50 who are just waving their arms around. Taiji players, this isn’t meant as a dig at you, YOU know which type you do and I don’t, I haven’t crossed hands with any of you.
So if you don’t want to get banned again kid learn how to comport yourself. Notify people when posting OT. If a thread will fit onto another forum more on-topic than in the main one than post it there instead. Don’t go name-dropping just to stick other forumites in the caky in order to get people off YOUR back. Try practicing some martial arts, any martial arts, and discuss your experiences in them rather than shooting off on the relative morality of internal vs external.
Capice?