Is this like Dim Mak?

I don’t know if this counts as dim mak or not. Um… they say if you get hit in the heart at just the right time between beats that you can die. Some kid just died like this playing soccer when the ball hit him in the heart.

Even if you were going to try to do this in a fight, it would be hard if not near impossible to know when their heart was at the right spot to hit. You’d have to like have a hand on their wrist to check their pulse or something.

But is this operating on the same principle as dim mak, or not?

IronFist

just keep hitting the heart continously and u’ll get it sooner or later:D

Re: Is this like Dim Mak?

All the “dim mak” training I’ve heard about has just been a methadology/pedagogy for training aimed striking. This “you die” or “you die later” stuff I’ve only ever encountered in novels, movies, and internet forums.

all my hits are dim mak hits. it just take longer for some people but everyone that i hit will die sooner or later. :cool:

Yeah, I’ve heard about this too. It supposedly happens every now and then in slow pitch softball. Apparently it needs to hit with just the right amount of force (it’s not too much) at the right time and at the right angle. There’s been some litigation over a couple of this rare occurrences (something about safety equipment) but I don’t know too much else about it.

Maybe a monk or whoever witnessed this phenomenon on a fight and decided it was chi or dim mak.

Hmmm

Um any strike to the head could cause a haemorrhage!!
Boxers cause brain haemorrhages but they don’t use Dian Xue.

There is no need for pre-medieval explanations here.

Besides stunning,the heart could go on beating rapidly but pumping no blood whatsoever,possibly resulting in death (I cannot recall the medical term for this condition).
But yeah,I think it would have to be the right angle,force etc.
It´s dim mak imho.

A powerful fist strike to the heart would generally be considered dangerous.

That was an attempt at mixing boxing and dim mak humor in a sardonic way. Obviously I failed. Back to the woodshed.:frowning:

JP, et al.

I’m pretty sure it was little league baseball and not slow pitch softball.

wait a sec…

http://www.aap.org/policy/re0032.html

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=92058881

gotta love that google.:slight_smile:

Happens in many sports, though extremely rare:

Maron, Barry J. MD et al, “Clinical Profile and Spectrum of Commotio Cordis” JAMA, March 6, 2002 – Vol 287, No. 9

I’d worry more about head trauma.