CLF monkey form

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7xQLZhWA-A

is it CLF or is it some other type of form.
Decent performance tho

It’s Choy Li Fut, both the Jiangmen and King Mui lines have monkey fist.

Never seen any monkey sets in CLF before. That looked like a contemporary wushu form to me.

This is a choy li fut monkey form. The individual performing this is an instructor from the Doc Fai Wong School in San Francisco. This was performed during Chan Heung’s (founder of Choy Li Fut) 200th birthday celebration banquet in JinagMen city in Guangdong China.
Cheers,
MK

First time I’ve ever heard of CLF having a monkey form & since when have CLF players actually mimicked the movements of animals in our forms, using the principles as found in the five animals yes but actually pretending to move like an animal.
I also find it interesting that the form is not listed in the Chan family list of forms.

I have never heard of any monkey Choy Lay Fut either. Does anyone know any details about this set?

Mano:

Actually the Chan Family does list it as part of their 10 animal forms. I read somewhere that Chan Yong Fa was good at this set as it fit his body. It mentioned his grandfather Chan Yiu Chi as teaching him the set. They also have a Monkey Pole set (not Hung Jeh Pang/Kwun).

I am with you about the mimicking and honestly this set does nothing for me. The guy doing it seems okay but the set itself doesn’t interest me.

[QUOTE=CLFNole;739125]Mano:

Actually the Chan Family does list it as part of their 10 animal forms. I read somewhere that Chan Yong Fa was good at this set as it fit his body. It mentioned his grandfather Chan Yiu Chi as teaching him the set. They also have a Monkey Pole set (not Hung Jeh Pang/Kwun).[/QUOTE]
Interesting. Do you know if the set in the video is the same one the Chan family lists?
[QUOTE=CLFNole;739125]I am with you about the mimicking and honestly this set does nothing for me. The guy doing it seems okay but the set itself does interest me.[/QUOTE]
I don’t know. I think the set is cool looking and mimicking aside, it looks like there is some useful stuff in there. I agree with you about the performer. He seems to move well.

Hou Ying Kuen is Hou Ying Kuen, whether it is done exactly like the Chan Family set I don’t know, its not a form that is taught that openly from what I’ve gathered.

As far as the set having useful stuff that is debatable as there isn’t much there to watch.

Personally I find the whole mimicking concept just for show, why do you need to act like and animal or act drunk. People know that you are not a monkey and not drunk so do you really think someone has a fighting advantage acting this way?

If a techinque is good it should work no matter how you act sober, drunk, like a monkey, crane, snake, etc… To me the spirit of the animal is what is more important and that is what most CLF animal forms will do, embrace the spirit more or less while using CLF core techniques. We don’t act like a tiger or panther or crane.

Thanks for the info.

Yeah I know what you mean. That’s what would lead me to guess this set is more for show. He did throw some strikes though and the agility required to do that form can’t hurt. That’s really what I saw useful out of it. I guess I look at this in a glass half-full kind of way.

Actually the Chan Family does list it as part of their 10 animal forms. I read somewhere that Chan Yong Fa was good at this set as it fit his body. It mentioned his grandfather Chan Yiu Chi as teaching him the set. They also have a Monkey Pole set (not Hung Jeh Pang/Kwun).

I am with you about the mimicking and honestly this set does nothing for me. The guy doing it seems okay but the set itself doesn’t interest me.

I may be wrong on the list.

Hou Ying Kuen is Hou Ying Kuen, whether it is done exactly like the Chan Family set I don’t know, its not a form that is taught that openly from what I’ve gathered.

As far as the set having useful stuff that is debatable as there isn’t much there to watch.

Personally I find the whole mimicking concept just for show, why do you need to act like and animal or act drunk. People know that you are not a monkey and not drunk so do you really think someone has a fighting advantage acting this way?

If a techinque is good it should work no matter how you act sober, drunk like a monkey, crane, snake, etc… To me the spirit of the animal is what is more important and that is what most CLF animal forms will do embrace the spirit more or less while using CLF core techniques. We don’t act like a tiger or panther or crane.

I couldn’t agree more with you

Mano:

I remember talking via email/forum with Howard Choy and he told me about the monkey sets that they have fist & pole. I was asking about Hung Jei Pang at the time and about the translation of the words. So call it Monkey King Staff while others translate it having to do with a pilgrimage of a monk, so its more of a monk staff.

Peace.

There is Monkey in CLF

Our school just held a seminar on the CLF monkey - I unfortunately missed it so I’m vague on details but it is there.

[QUOTE=The Xia;739123]I have never heard of any monkey Choy Lay Fut either. Does anyone know any details about this set?[/QUOTE]
How’s your Chinese?
http://www.plumblossom.net/PhotoAlbum/KingMuiVillage/kingmuiscripts.html

monkey what???

I have an issue of Black belt magazine from 20 years ago that has Doc Fai Wong demoing a monkey pole, which aside from the facial expressions he made in the pics was essentially the same as the double endded pole my sifu taugh me (which he learned from a northern mizong lohan sifu)

as for this vid, the performance was okay i guess. There just wasn’t much there. I only saw one CLF technique maybe two in the whole thing. My freind Sifu Sharrif from Yee’s Hung Ga in NY recently put some cool Hung Ga monkey footage up. He is preforming lau Ka Lueng’s monkey set, and while it emphasises the acting it also contains high level fighting theory. Check it out!

http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&videoID=1601181474

I hope the unabridged version of this form is a little more substantive??

I have an issue of Black belt magazine from 20 years ago that has Doc Fai Wong demoing a monkey pole, which aside from the facial expressions he made in the pics was essentially the same as the double endded pole my sifu taugh me (which he learned from a northern mizong lohan sifu)

I don’t know the CLF monkey staff, but I do know the Hung monkey staff and it is not monkey at all. Where single end staff is king in Guangdong styles it would appear that many double ended forms are just called monkey staff. Plus also there’s the allusion to the monkey king from Journey to the West, which would make

while others translate it having to do with a pilgrimage of a monk
make a lot of sense. If the monkey in question is the monkey king, then monkey imitation is less important, and techniques that lengthen and shorten the effective area of staff come to the fore (the monkey king’s staff was supposed to change length at will).
I think some of you are being a bit harsh about the video. For starters it’s edited, and if you’re going to edit a monkey form you’re going to keep the OTT imitation and leave out the more subtle stuff, and there is some nice sweeping and low line kicking in the clip.
IMO there’s nothing wrong with imitation, as long as it’s functional.

Well, it looks nice, he acts like a little monkey but i really can’t get it why it would be functional aside from the lowkicks and sweeps.
I once saw a shaolin demo with one of the kids performing a monkeyform. It looked very similar. Jumping about, weird facial expressions scratching etc.:stuck_out_tongue:
Monkey’s allways been a secretive and elusive art. Not openly taught. So perhaps the masters are keeping it to themselfs, only to teach it to a handfull;)

[QUOTE=WhiteEarp;741887]Well, it looks nice, he acts like a little monkey but i really can’t get it why it would be functional aside from the lowkicks and sweeps.
I once saw a shaolin demo with one of the kids performing a monkeyform. It looked very similar. Jumping about, weird facial expressions scratching etc.:stuck_out_tongue:
Monkey’s allways been a secretive and elusive art. Not openly taught. So perhaps the masters are keeping it to themselfs, only to teach it to a handfull;)[/QUOTE]

dai sing pek gwa is a popular monkey style with axe fist
so i dont know wat you mean by secretive art