Choy Lay Fut Sap Ji Kau Da Kuen

[QUOTE=hskwarrior;1083472]yeah i agree. but if you compare the two sets and know where things were changed you’d see that they are the same. And sorry brah, i was just generally speaking[/QUOTE]

Haha, no need for apologies. You should know me too well by now. :smiley:

Shaolindynasty,

Thanks for sharing! Your version is very different from the Sup Ji Kau Da that I learned, but I enjoy seeing different versions of things within CLF. It’s interesting how forms that share the same name within the same system (though different in lineage) will vary, sometimes dramatically due to the preferences/experiences of different masters over time.

Excellent performance, by the way. Keep up the good work.

We still have both crane & tiger in our hoi jung.

nospam
:cool:

We still have both crane & tiger in our hoi jung.

nospam

Yeah I’ve seen you guys do it. but other buk sing schools have taken the crane out completely.

[QUOTE=hskwarrior;1083716]Yeah I’ve seen you guys do it. but other buk sing schools have taken the crane out completely.[/QUOTE]

Can you link a video showing the Hoi Jong with Crane element replaced by Tiger?

give me time i have to look

Here is one video that shows the Tiger Claw where palms should be:

look at the first 5 movements

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i7XUCgxrVXc&playnext=1&list=PL46A62F76A589625D

Here you can see how we use all palms:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DuFwlduAQnI

There looks to be a bit of crane in the buk sing opening.

there are too many buk sing vids for me to go through right now. but i did say that in the first few moves you will see the tiger claw. he actually does three tiger claws in the first three moves.. Fut San including lau bun’s lineage doesn’t we use palms. so somewhere down the line buk sing changed it to include the tiger claws.

That might be true but they didn’t remove the crane. It is there in the hoi jong.

Well, they did take away the essence of the crane in one sense. The Tiger and the Crane is not just in the hand shapes as well. But our Hoi Jong FLOWS with the tiger/crane essence as well.

but yeah i know they still have some crane…maybe it was the lacey lineage i was thinking of but i remember asking my friends what happened to the Crane essence along time ago.