I have always kinda felt like Kung Fu was somewhat…I guess unrealistic for real world situations. No disrespect meant by that it’s just that I have Hollywood images running through my head of people flying around and things of that nature. However I have been reading a little about Wing Chun and just how well it works in real world situation. Anyway, I wanted to hear from you guys because I really know nothing about it other than Bruce Lee studied it at one time. So would you guys recommend it? I want something both effective and somewhat traditional. Also I’m looking at moving to Phoenix Arizona and was looking at this school.
What he is saying is that Wing Chun is plagued by inner-style bickering, jockeying, and lineage issues, that will ruin your perception of the art. Internet message boards are the battleground on which these issues are fought.
I’ll compare it by way of post counts, you have 4, I have 5990. Trust me on this, run, while you still can. Go to your school, check it out, make some freinds, learn some kungfu, more importantly have some fun. Don’t bother with anyone who says they study with wingchun on the internet.
I’d like to paint a picture here: Your a fly, and your hovering there carefree before the flypaper. I’m here stuck to the flypaper aka kungfumagazine forums, and I’m telling you, don’t touch it, don’t even look at it too long. don’t say the whole name in the same sentence if you can help it!!!
Having been in your shoes before, I would say the thing to do is determine what your goals are, then look at the school and see if the higher ranking students exhibit the skills/qualities that you get from your martial arts training. If they cannot fight and your goal is to be a good fighter, the school in question might not be right for you. How do you determine this? This is a difficult question. You can ask them about their classes of course, and watching a class would be a good idea too. Wing chun is considered an effective art for self-defense, but more important than the style is how it is practiced at the school. But if you work hard all your training will pay off in the end…for example I’ve bounced around from a couple different places b/c I would meet some guy at my ninjutsu school that did kung fu then some guy at kung fu that did san shou…so I found places that I liked…
BTW I can tell you that the statement below is true for at least large martial arts org. but I daren’y say which for fear that a ninja will sneak into my house at night pretending to be a cameraman…anyway…
There is this large martial arts org. where if you look on the internet they will say: “Only go to schools that can show you written documentation verifying their good standing with the grandmaster of the style” Sounds like an attempt to keep the system up to par when in fact all you have to do is send $$$ and you will receive said documentation…so I guess what I am trying to tell you is that I wouldn’t choose schools based on paperwork or memorabilia, but rather by watching them perform their martial art. I had to say this b/c many schools might try to lure you in with such strategies while you may be passing over a good one that didn’t send in the money if you adhere to aforementioned philosophy. Hope this helps and g/l.
Here’s the problem BSC14, you’re gonna get several opinions. Some might have had good experiences with the school and so will say good things. Some will have had bad experiences with the school and say bad things, most of us have never heard of the effin place and won’t say a whole lot, and all teh wingchun guys will tell you it sucks, unless they share the same lineage.
Go check out the school, see how YOU feel about it. Check out some other schools in your area and see how you feel about them. Then choose.
Better yet, give each school a month, visit a couple, spend a month checking them out then see how you feel.
but if you really want to learn to fight you’ll take BJJ or TKD.
Originally posted by red5angel but if you really want to learn to fight you’ll take BJJ or TKD.
Actually, the first step is to check if you’re a mammal. Do you have nipples? Good. This means that you’re destined to be a ninja. As such, your mission will be to infiltrate the Wing Chun school, attain an intermediate rank, and then flip out and kill everybody with your sweet ninja skillz. Then seek out Ashida Kim to complete your ninja training. Just be careful if he looks like he’s going to flip out. And don’t touch his nipples.
Please don’t take kung fu, especially not traditional…
It’s full of kooks who dress up in Chinese silk pajamas, talk in a funny language, think they can shoot chi out of there palms and quite frankly just don’t know how to fight.
I’d recommend BJJ, MMA, Muy Thai or anything that sounds new and “razzle dazzle” like Krav Maga or Shaolin Kempo.
Anything where you get sweaty and wrestle around on the ground is good because that is more like real fighting. Afterall, 90% of fights go to the ground and are one-on-one so that’s really where you want to put your training effort.
Anything where you spar “full contact” with pads (wait isn’t than an oxymoron?) is good because chances are when you get in a real fight your opponent is going to be wearing boxing gloves (and you’ll be wearing protective head gear).
I’d also try to avoid anything that has a history of more than 20 years because it means that art is “dead” but if you train something that is less than 20 years old and has a razzle dazzle name like Mixed Martial arts or “Free hand” then you are training a “Modern Defense Concept.”
And heaven knows you wouldn’t want to train anything that isn’t “modern.”
I’d also recommend when you start training that you do a heavy dose of weightlifting. Bodybuilding and martial arts work really well together. If you can isolate one muscle to be very strong then when you use all your muscles together they will be super strong. Coordination will come in and of itself. Just keep lifting.
Avoid any weapon training. It’s pointless. I mean where are you gonna find a Halberd or Spear or Broadsword or the street. Go for simpler weapons like 2 sticks or a Bowie knife (because most people carry those around.) Instead of weapon training get back in the gym and keep lifting those weights.
Just some friendly advice from a traditional kung fu guy who knows nothing about fighting.
Looks like a typical Kung Fu school from the waesite. Fairly nice, so they are likely well established and profitable and large. But the point isn’t what they look like on paper, it’s will that school work for you.
I’m sure you are starting to get sick of hearing this, but it’s true. I personnaly don’t like the bigger schools. I don’t feel comfortable in large classes where I don’t really know many of my fellow students. I spend more of my time worrying about not looking silly. But if you are the kind of person who isn’t as self-conssious, that won’t likely be an issue.
Another big thing to think about is wether your personality meshes well with the instructor’s. If it doesn’t, you won’t be satified with your training, no mater how good the school is.
The best thing you can do is visit the school, talk with people, and try it out. If you feel comfortable in that environment, the classes fit your schedule and you can afford it, stay. If not go look somewhere else. Any oppinion you get on the web will probably not be very reliable unless they are a student of that school. This is point Red5 was trying (and failing horrably) to make.
"Anything where you spar “full contact” with pads (wait isn’t than an oxymoron?) is good because chances are when you get in a real fight your opponent is going to be wearing boxing gloves (and you’ll be wearing protective head gear). "
So are you saying its better to point spar or not spar at all?
"Bodybuilding and martial arts work really well together. If you can isolate one muscle to be very strong then when you use all your muscles together they will be super strong. Coordination will come in and of itself. Just keep lifting. "
If you know how to lift weights for shit, you know that you can work muscles and support groups with free weights, then move to machines and isolate muscles and work them until exhaustion. God knows that fighting is easier when you are a peasy little b!tch.
"Avoid any weapon training. It’s pointless. I mean where are you gonna find a Halberd or Spear or Broadsword or the street. "
This was sarcastic, but funnily enough, correct. It is pointless. Fun, but pointless. Only weapons you would want to train to use would be a pocket knife, a stick, or a gun. Other than that, its all for fun.
Dont read too much into this thread BSC 14… Just check out the school and see what you think. Make your own opionions based on what goals you have and how applicable to your goals said school is.
