What are the main differences between these two theories? I’m not very versed in the trapping area and was just wondering what the difference from workin the clinch would be.
Hope we get good discussion.
Later, Brad
What are the main differences between these two theories? I’m not very versed in the trapping area and was just wondering what the difference from workin the clinch would be.
Hope we get good discussion.
Later, Brad
In my JKD school, we use trapping as a means to get TO the clinch, in theory we use trapping to get past the opponents arms/defence and when his arms are trapped, we transition to clinch, which should then become the end of the fight itself (use elbows, knees, headbutts)
That is just ONE way.
clinching is usually just two guys getting tangled up in each other.
trapping is calculated defenses on incoming attacks. Trapping is not related to clinching.
Clinching just happens, Trappingm you train to do.
cheers
Not entirely correct, since Muay Thai & other arts trains specifically for the clinch as an offensive/defensive tactic.
![]()
clinching is a type or part of trapping range.
this is entirely untrue:
[i]clinching is usually just two guys getting tangled up in each other.
trapping is calculated defenses on incoming attacks. Trapping is not related to clinching.
Clinching just happens, Trappingm you train to do.[/i]
cheers.
:eek:
the trapping as contained in the styles I practice consists of establishing a contact with your opponent’s arms and seal them in a position where their mobility is reduced or anihilated. For example one common trapping is that is someone assumed a boxing gard in front of you you quickly squeeze their forearms or elbows one against the other, or agains the opponent’s body.
Trapping doesn’t necessarily involve a grab, but often a simple contact with the palms and a push…it is also often not necessarily a long push but can be a short strong pulse to destabilize your opponent (in any case, trapping is done in my style by pushing the opponents limbs one against the others, or against the body, or any position that reduces mobility and strike opportunities for him). By the time he recovers his structure yourself have an opportunity to strike…it’s quite easy to show but hard to describe…
the clinch, as I understand it, on the other hand, is more of a rush to grab your opponent’s body, whether the neck or shoulder area and establishing a firm hold close to him to reduce the power of any hand strike. This also enables you to follow with knees or sometimes elbows (in some situations), or wrestling, take downs etc…
I specifically use trapping to allow a flanking footwork maneuver w/o danger of getting hit while flanking. If the trap works, of course.
Trapping is not clinching but clinching can be trapping.
Clinching is NOT ‘just two guys getting tangled up’.
I think KUNG LEK is joking!
Trapping deals with controlling the arms/legs of an opponent via grabbling or slapping while striking. Reference point is usally the elbow…if u watch hidden tiger/crouching dragon…u see alot of trapping in the h2h combat.
Clinching deals with controlling the arms, neck and upper body…u can see this in wrestling…and muy thai.
Each method is used in the proper situation/condition.
![]()
Use your arms and legs.
:rolleyes:
In practice, there are quite a few differences (I actually hadn’t connected the two before reading this), but I suppose the theories are similar. In trapping, you temporarily immobilize or control an opponent’s limb(s) to gain the upper hand. When clinching, the idea is to gain control of the other person’s head/neck and from there throw them out of the ring, hit them with a knee strike or whatever technique you want to use. So I suppose in some ways they are similar…
you would not believe the length, clarity and brilliance of the answer i just typed, only to have it lost to the mysteries of the net.
so i’ll just have to say: ask your freaking sifu!
![]()
i’ll try and get back to it later…![]()
Originally posted by Kung Lek
[B]clinching is usually just two guys getting tangled up in each other.
trapping is calculated defenses on incoming attacks. Trapping is not related to clinching.
Clinching just happens, Trappingm you train to do.
cheers [/B]
:rolleyes:
to me
to trap is to trick, put the fool in a position where he got fooled and is in a bad position. like 1, 2, 3 and his arms are in a crappy position where he can no longer attack you and you got yourself in a position where you can beat him more easily.
so trapping happens in clinching too
the WC guys definition of what trapping should me make me go like: Huh? Like… huh?
huh?
Second knee in clinch:

Damage from first knee:

what you say?
(they set up us the bomb)
really, what are the pictures supposed to mean?
My opinion (and that’s all it is): They describe the same range. But trapping tends to describe a focus on the opponent’s limbs. Whereas clinching tends to focus on the trunk, head, and neck.
Obviously, those are kinda fuzzy distinctions. Someone trapping an arm is ultimately going to want to elbow the head, for example. Likewise, someone looking to clinch is probably going to have to at least sweep an opponent’s arm out of the way first.
But when I think of clinching in, say, boxing or muay thai, the emphasis is on tying the arms to the trunk or controlling the head and neck, respectively. Whereas in, for example, wing chun or kali (arts in which the term ‘trapping’ is used), there is an emphasis on controlling at the forearm or elbow, or tricep, etc. Before countering to the core of the opponent.
All that said, it’s just terminology. I personally wouldn’t have a problem with calling trapping ‘limb clinching’ or clinching ‘neck trapping.’ Or something.
Regardless, I disagree with Kung Lek’s statement (or joke?) that clinching is uncontrolled and incidental.
Stuart B.
There are methods that you can employ when you find yourself in a clinch. There is even training devised around what to do in a clinch.
Most fighters do not try to get into a clinch although there may be a trend towards training for it now. For the most part, a clinch is two guys getting tangled and now they must get out of it, the one who is prepared for it and knows what to do will likely fair better.
Trapping can be used in a clinch, but trapping and the clinch are entirely different. A boxer does not box to find themself in a clinch. A striker does not seek to clinch and it is wrestling that will teach you more about a lockup that is a clinch.
The clinch is used primarily to stop your opponent from attacking you and to get a little rest. The trap is used to setup a break or lock which will end a given situation.
No, I’m not joking.
regards
Vanderlei Silva has a good clinch ![]()
No, I’m not joking
Muay thai fighters don’t train to go to the clinch? They just find themselves there and then train to make the best of it?
Nah. I don’t believe that. Controlling the head and body so that you can deliver knee strikes to the body, legs, and head are very deliberate tactics. Not strikes of happenstance.
Most fighters do not try to get into a clinch although there may be a trend towards training for it now. For the most part, a clinch is two guys getting tangled and now they must get out of it, the one who is prepared for it and knows what to do will likely fair better.
I don’t really believe that. I believe it’s often a transition stage. Something you use on the way to takedowns. To rest for a moment without absorbing blows. Or to achieve a level of hands-on control for striking.
I do agree that fighters do get tangled up and that good clinchers will be at an advantage in that case. But I think it’s wrong to suggest that nobody seeks to clinch on purpose. Resting, wearing an opponent out, setting up for a throw, setting up for knees, etc. All are deliberate.
Trapping can be used in a clinch, but trapping and the clinch are entirely different. A boxer does not box to find themself in a clinch. A striker does not seek to clinch and it is wrestling that will teach you more about a lockup that is a clinch.
Muay thai stylists are strikers that seek to clinch. So how can this statement be true? As for boxers, it’s not ideal to clinch perhaps. But it’s a common enough tactic to clinch with someone in order to rest or smother the opponent’s offense so you can gather your wits. In both cases, the boxer decides to clinch.
The clinch is used primarily to stop your opponent from attacking you and to get a little rest.
In boxing, yes. Precisely. So how does that just happen? You don’t tangle up and then decide it’s an ideal time to take a rest.
The trap is used to setup a break or lock which will end a given situation.
Every time? Usually, when I’ve seen a pak sao for example, the trap was used to land a strike. And while, ideally, the strike will take the opponent out, that’s hardly a given. Meaning that trapping is not necessarily used to set up a break or lock and will not necessarily end a given situation. (Though, ideally, virtually any move a martial artist performs will end a given situation.)
Stuart B.