I am curious what some of you practitioners of traditional Chinese Martial art and “you other people” 
have to say about the Horse Stance in training and application?
Is it valuable? Essential? Useless? How low should you go? What’s the highest you’d want to stand? How long should you hold it? Should you hold it at all? What is the longest you personally have ever held it?
I’ve been meditating on the basics quite a bit and I have some thoughts to share.
Peace
hi d00d
stances are fundamental skills, but horse stance skill “pillar skill” takes a lot of hard work its one of the hardest skills to learn in kung fu. its to stop takedown
people ask why it no work its useless why it doenst work? its one of the hardest skills to learn
piece and chicken grease
[QUOTE=bawang;908852]hi d00d
stances are fundamental skills, but horse stance skill “pillar skill” takes a lot of hard work its one of the hardest skills to learn in kung fu. its to stop takedown
people ask why it no work its useless why it doenst work? its one of the hardest skills to learn
piece and chicken grease[/QUOTE]
Excellent input! The Horse Stance is the place where many things begin and end.
Stance training, helps build focus and discipline. Builds leg muscle. Aids in rooting concepts.
I was told toe fwd, thighs parallel to the ground is a good mah bu. I have never been able to do that. :o
The longest for me was 5mins. I started daydreaming about this chick also in mah bu in front of me. Then the instructor had as switch to gong bu. That totally ruined my fantasy. :o
if you just do horse stance you can never stand long
you also need to do squats and running
whenever you have free time go in horse stance when i wash dishes and eat i do horse stance
im in horse stance right now
Our teachers are big on the horse stance training. The way they teach the stance training, the feet are five spread-hands apart and the thighs are parallel to the ground with back straight and toes pointing forward. They want you to hold it at that level a minimum of two minutes.
While I see the value in it, I personally hate holding a horse stance. but you do lots of things you hate because you see the value in it anyway.
If I just stand in a horse stance I can usually “last” about 3-4 min, BUT if I am doing other stuff, like hand form or rolling a metal bar or grip work, before I know it 10-15 min will pass.
Of course by that time the horse has left and ate all my carrots, that rat *******.
Funny you should bring this up on the Shaolin forum
We just ran Traditional Shaolin Stance Training By Walter Gjergja in our 2009 January/February Shaolin Special, which is still on the newsstands for one more week.
Gives me one more chance to plug it. Thanks.
[QUOTE=GeneChing;908993]We just ran Traditional Shaolin Stance Training By Walter Gjergja in our 2009 January/February Shaolin Special, which is still on the newsstands for one more week.
Gives me one more chance to plug it. Thanks.[/QUOTE]
Cool! Hey did you ever run that sword thing we talked about?
[QUOTE=Judge Pen;908946]Our teachers are big on the horse stance training. The way they teach the stance training, the feet are five spread-hands apart and the thighs are parallel to the ground with back straight and toes pointing forward. They want you to hold it at that level a minimum of two minutes.
While I see the value in it, I personally hate holding a horse stance. but you do lots of things you hate because you see the value in it anyway.[/QUOTE]
What you describe is the ideal horse stance or the box (seated root) which is second to the Up Right ready stance. The key transition between these two are Pigeon toe stance or female horse.
So after you’ve spent time developing the seated root and the transitions in and out of it, what can you do with it?
What should you do with it in your training, in life or death combat or at work humping around 50 lbs bags of corn and rice? I’ve had some interesting revelations about it in combat, but in my everyday life it has been a blessing.
Stepping wrong on an icy street, what could have resulted a broken bone or bruised ego only turned into sliding horse stance.
A combination of too much beer, soap suds, hot water, bad footing and a voluptuous woman in an all glass shower enclosure might have been a disaster for someone whom knows someone I know. I’m not mentioning any names but instead he ended in horse stance bruising his heal as he caught himself saving their collective sudsy a s ses. I hear she was very very greatful LOL!:rolleyes:
Lets talk more about this Horse Stance Thing.
[QUOTE=Judge Pen;908946]Our teachers are big on the horse stance training. The way they teach the stance training, the feet are five spread-hands apart and the thighs are parallel to the ground with back straight and toes pointing forward. They want you to hold it at that level a minimum of two minutes.
While I see the value in it, I personally hate holding a horse stance. but you do lots of things you hate because you see the value in it anyway.[/QUOTE]
What part of the thighs parallel? I assume you mean the front(top) of the thighs.
Some people tend to do that back of the thighs parallel.
let’s talk more about naked wimmins in showers covered in suds and a little tipsy! 
[QUOTE=David Jamieson;909105]let’s talk more about naked wimmins in showers covered in suds and a little tipsy! :p[/QUOTE]
Some people, we need to stick on the subject:
[QUOTE=sanjuro_ronin;909111]Some people, we need to stick on the subject:[/QUOTE]
dude, stay on topic. that second pic is a BOW stance. this is about horse stance man…sheesh:rolleyes:
the basic form of the horse stance, ie: legs bent, weight dropped, ass tucked, etc. regardless of how high, or how your toes are pointed, is used in so many different aspects of combat.
of course i dont take one stance out from the rest, you have to practice them all. along with the strength training, muscular endurance/developent, flexability. you get to a point where all the stances are just connection points of movement.
to me the stances each have a large degree of variation, because i live in a world of movement. combat is not static, so your stances, when applied in combat will not be static either. however for some training purposes they will be.
take grappling for instance. in a grappling match, you will commonly see bow and horse stance of some variation, being moved into and out of on a continual basis. until the throw/takedown we are always in some stance unless we are standing upright and perfectly still.
many people will not agree with me, and will argue that there is only one way to do a stance. ive pointed to spots where guys are using a horse stance to keep their base as they pefrom, say a suplex, and had people tell me that its not a horse stance. ive always taken what i learn and see how it fits into the reality of violent action.
to me thats using your horsestance in a form of combat. whether you use the stance for a brief moment of transition to execute a throw or what have you. during that moment of time when you are using the stance, your entire being of combat is dependant on that stance holding up and being strong enough to do what you need it to do.
mind you i learned all my stances and foundational development in tcma. it is what i practice currently. i just like to keep in mind that combat is combat, regardless of what style i may prefer or like, the truth is always the truth.
i used to meditate in a low horse for around 30 minutes. now the only static stance training i do is what i learned from i-chuan. the rest of what i do is involved in movement.
as to the original question, if you view the horse stance from a similar angle as i do, not only is it usefull, it is an essential part of combat movment.
a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
and now i have to go back to work:mad:
Lokhopkuen’s Deer Horn Knives are in the next issue.
Lokhopkuen, I PMed you about the sword, et.al.
Once again, I gotta score this thread to sanjuro_ronin. He has one simple direct attack, but he almost always scores with it. Bow stance indeed. Like we really care…
[QUOTE=GeneChing;909130]Lokhopkuen, I PMed you about the sword, et.al.
Once again, I gotta score this thread to sanjuro_ronin. He has one simple direct attack, but he almost always scores with it. Bow stance indeed. Like we really care… :p[/QUOTE]
lol, once again gene smothers me with his sagely wisdom 
[QUOTE=sanjuro_ronin;909111]Some people, we need to stick on the subject:[/QUOTE]
Hayden,+Diana+-martial+arts.jpg (18.4 KB, 1 views)
Hips bellow the knees. Not good geometry but very sexy indeed.
kelly+hu+-sexy.jpg (13.0 KB, 1 views)
Heels are off the floor in her bow stance not good but once again very sexy indeed.
[QUOTE=Lucas;909128]dude, stay on topic. that second pic is a BOW stance. this is about horse stance man…sheesh:rolleyes:
the basic form of the horse stance, ie: legs bent, weight dropped, ass tucked, etc. regardless of how high, or how your toes are pointed, is used in so many different aspects of combat.
of course i dont take one stance out from the rest, you have to practice them all. along with the strength training, muscular endurance/developent, flexability. you get to a point where all the stances are just connection points of movement.
to me the stances each have a large degree of variation, because i live in a world of movement. combat is not static, so your stances, when applied in combat will not be static either. however for some training purposes they will be.
take grappling for instance. in a grappling match, you will commonly see bow and horse stance of some variation, being moved into and out of on a continual basis. until the throw/takedown we are always in some stance unless we are standing upright and perfectly still.
many people will not agree with me, and will argue that there is only one way to do a stance. ive pointed to spots where guys are using a horse stance to keep their base as they pefrom, say a suplex, and had people tell me that its not a horse stance. ive always taken what i learn and see how it fits into the reality of violent action.
to me thats using your horsestance in a form of combat. whether you use the stance for a brief moment of transition to execute a throw or what have you. during that moment of time when you are using the stance, your entire being of combat is dependant on that stance holding up and being strong enough to do what you need it to do.
mind you i learned all my stances and foundational development in tcma. it is what i practice currently. i just like to keep in mind that combat is combat, regardless of what style i may prefer or like, the truth is always the truth.
i used to meditate in a low horse for around 30 minutes. now the only static stance training i do is what i learned from i-chuan. the rest of what i do is involved in movement.
as to the original question, if you view the horse stance from a similar angle as i do, not only is it usefull, it is an essential part of combat movment.
a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
and now i have to go back to work:mad:[/QUOTE]
Well said! This is the type of thing I was fishing for. More!
gene smothers me with his sagely wisdom
Can’t see the forest for the trees.
Can’t see the horse stance for the knees.
One of my shimei, the first got qi? girl no less, once told me that you can’t look sexy in a proper horse stance no matter how hard you try. She thought that was the main problem with kung fu.
I’m learning Wu Family Style Taijiquan. I’ve only been at it about a year and a half. I’ve been taught to hold a fairly high horse stance as a beginning form of zhan zhuang.