Totally Descriptive To Say Stance Instead of the Vague Horse? I No_Know
YinOrYan,
"Even using the unique names of each move can be make their minds wander. The same goes for even somewhat descriptive terms like "horse" because something like a square-horse can make some people think of absurd things like chess moves"
Wander to where except to the imagery relating to the scene name? And can’t it be part of mastery to explore the form so a wandering mind opens the student to learning. The instructor guides and steps to mastery are not lost steps to have full imagery at the beginning, but your example was not full, So, so Sorr.
horse might bring an image of chess moves until one just stands there with spread knees and feet two shoulder’s width apart. And the chess move is patently “L” shaped in how it is generally thought-of so no one should think of a move by standing in place nor think of the rectangular knight piece move in an “L” pattern when someone in a Kung-Fu or Taiji stance-scenario or forms class says square horse…Just shouldn’t regularly happen-Ernie Moore Jr
When someone is saying Horse hopefully it is in a Kung-Fu or Taiji class, and not on a bus or Times Square. In the context of location and timing even if someone does not understand horse means Horse stance as riding a horse one might normally ride. A few mentions should sort-out any confusion as you brought-up so, that if they keep attending, saying horse when about to transition to a standing move-one might get that this relates strongly to acquiring a stance of Horse-riding. By-the-way, The stabilizing thing a carpenter might use or in construction seems to be called a work horse and I am not experienced in exposure enough to think people regularly refer to a work Horse as “Horse” as these people are labor and often newer and so more fuller terms are used initially.-Ernie Moore Jr.
Saying stance is not necessarily as you say, totally descriptive. By itself Stance only means one…hundred things…(O. K. 01) Entering stance, 02) Reverse stance, 03) Right stance, 04) Center stance, 05) Left stance, 06) Cross stance, 07) Cross-Step((p)ing) stance, 08)seven-star stance, 09) Cat stance, 10) Horse stance, 11) Horse-riding stance, 12) Riding-Horse stance, 13) Front-Knee-Bent stance, 14) Ape stance 15) Dragon-Walking stance, 16) 60-40 stance, 17) 40-60 stance, 18) 50-50 stance, 19) Crane stance, 20) Twisting stance, 21) Bow and Arrow stance, 22) Dragon stance, 23) Scissors stance…) …so yes use stance coupled with a description. And do not use just one word of a descriptive phrase and Not include the term stance. But I started this thinking you were saying say stance and they do the right one instinctively with nothing else because you didn’t like saying horse to say horse riding stance…where as in square-horse-square augments horse, horse determines the general posture. But these are instructions within a technique which can be Hit-or-Miss. But Brush Knee and push really takes you there if you do not struggle. White Crane might be much if people don’t see cranes. Either get that it is a bird or change the name to a more familiar, such as Bird Spreads Its Wings then they follow you, but they want to flap because the birds they see just have small wings and flap so your move seems off, show them a picture, tell them a scene of a long winged bird and the move resembles that scene of a White Crane Spreading its Wings. Should be fine.-Ernie Moore Jr.
You do not have to say Square horse. One could use more words with not too much sweat and fill-that-out with the original–Squared-off Horse-riding Stance. But if they did not learn the original terms; then only knowing a short-cut name that misses being descriptive for the uninitiated and maybe shortening of a short. It seems that could be unhelpful in a starting. But it was for me and I am not there. And anyone familiar with the scenery who is told the move resembles the moves of the image or scene can come closer to getting the move more right, more quickly, more often.-Ernie Moore Jr.
If mentions were because I was taking a class or relearning or forgot the form and the thought of me as New to this all…O.K. Thank you for your considerations and situationally widely accepted practical advice.-Ernie Moore Jr.
No_Know