The Variety review
I like the global market perspective of this review - good comments on PRC vs. US viability.
Police Story 2013 Review
March 3, 2014 | 06:40PM PT
Jackie Chan makes a dull departure from his former kickass shenanigans in this rickety action-drama.
Maggie Lee @maggiesama
A hostage action-drama so sedate it suggests a remake of Die Hard by Yoji Yamada, Police Story 2013 feels as old and tired as the character played by its leading man, Jackie Chan. As a self-martyring Beijing cop up against a cold-blooded kidnapper with sister issues, Chan makes a dull departure from his former kickass shenanigans, and Ding Sheng (Little Big Soldier, also toplined by Chan), a mainland helmer-scribe of only moderate talent, can neither build nor sustain tension and emotional heft over the course of a faulty, circuitous plot. While this rickety star vehicle grossed well over $86 million in China, overseas prospects look less optimistic.
Although it borrows its title from Police Story, one of Chans feistiest stunt extravaganzas, and its three sequels (released between 1985 and 1996), this mainland production is a completely unrelated affair in terms of plot and spirit; nor does it have anything to do with New Police Story (2004), Benny Chans flashier update of the franchise. The new actually stems from the popular tradition of mainland TV cop dramas gritty, socially realistic procedurals with unabashedly moralistic overtones that enjoy a steady provincial viewer base. Its a genre that helmers like Gao Qunshu (Old Fish, Beijing Blues) have skillfully transferred to the bigscreen, but Ding lacks the cinematic instincts to make the transfer work, and the plot holes become all the more noticeable under his slack pacing.
Police captain Zhong (Chan) is called to an aggressively hip underground club by daughter Miaomiao (Jing Tian), who walked out on him six months earlier. Finding her dangling from the arm of owner Wu Jiang (Liu Ye, The Last Supper), whose diabolical grin and tank of pet piranhas are the epitome of shady, Zhong launches the first of his many self-righteous lectures on Miaomiaos goth getup, her tattoos and her dodgy b.f. but she lashes back, blaming his workaholic ways for her mothers untimely death. They are interrupted by a suicide-bomb crisis, which turns out to be just a prelude to the real trouble: Wu has lured everyone to his hive in an elaborate kidnapping plan.
While a typical Hong Kong movie would have orchestrated a propulsive clash by this point, the police reinforcements dont lead to any real action, and Zhong spends an inordinate amount of time playing the master negotiator. One of the films most trying aspects is the fact that nearly every scene is set indoors, with quick flashes of action mostly occurring elsewhere in a different time frame, such as a cross-country car chase or an overseas fight-club match-up. On neither a narrative nor an emotion level do any of these setpieces connect smoothly with the escalating conflict in the bar.
The only full-fledged action sequence is a mano-a-mano between Zhong and Wus Filippino cohort, Pichon (Liu Hailong), a brutal punch-up with little in the way of refined choreography, but at least a few body parts get dislocated. Even then, the screenplay milks Zhongs heavy bruising for maximum sentimental effect, with hostages so moved by their experience that they beg not to be released.
It takes nearly 50 minutes for the film to get to Wus backstory, and another half-hour before the denouement reveals how a past incident altered the lives of Wus sister Xiaowei (Guli Nazha) and Zhongs wife. Much thought and planning has gone into Dings screenplay, slotting the actors and multiple plot strands into a neat scheme of cause and effect. However, tension gradually dissipates amid repeated shifts back to the bar, where the key figures engage in Ras****n-style confessions directed in a dry, stagelike manner.
Liu (who starred in Dings action comedies The Underdog Knight and He-man) invests his role with moral ambivalence, his brooding presence suggesting considerable emotional baggage, even though the reasons for his crimes and nihilism surface too late too sink in on a dramatic level. The film could have drawn more engaging parallels between Zhong and Wu as men fighting an unjust world while sacrificing women they love in the process; however, Chans demonstrative acting doesnt gel with Lius subtler performing style, and the film misses its chance to be a gripping psychological two-hander. At 59, Chan not only looks tired, his self-punishing bravado yielding diminishing returns, but he has also become an altogether a sententious figure, endlessly spouting moral platitudes or nationalist rhetoric onscreen.
Jing (From Vegas to Macau) drops her feline sexiness after a few scenes, as Miaomiao converts to dutiful daughter so early on that theres no room to develop a satisfying journey of understanding and reconciliation with her father. Her sole function henceforth is to worry about Zhongs safety. The hostages form a colorful ensemble, but none of them gets the chance round out a real personality.
Tech credits are serviceable. Production design centers on the bar, converted from a metal factory whose industrial chic soon wears off, as the lighting, all glaring neons or sooty darkness, lacks variation. Lensing by Ding Yu, a regular of the directors, is competent but stylistically indifferent. Lao Zais score is generic until it starts slipping in belly-dancing music into action scenes with mind-bogging results.
Version caught in HK was screened 2D but in China, it was released as a 3D conversion and on IMAX.
Film Review: ‘Police Story 2013’
Reviewed at Windsor Cinema, Hong Kong, Jan. 11, 2014. Running time: 110 MIN. (Original title: “Jincha gushi 2013”)
Production
(China-Hong Kong) A Jackie & JJ Prods. (in Hong Kong)/Wanda Media Co. (in China) release of a Jackie & JJ Prods., Wanda Media Co., Starlit HK Intl. Media Co., presentation of a Jackie & JJ Prods., Emperor Motion Pictures production in association with China Film Group, China Movie Channel, Xi’an Dragon Films & TV Culture. (International sales:Jackie & JJ Intl., Hong Kong.) Produced by Jackie Chan. Executive producers, Jackie Chan, Ye Ning, Lu Zheng, Gillian Zhao, Han Xiaoli, Liu Jiawei, Li Jianhua, Lu Hongshi. Co-producers, Abe Kwong Man-wai, Zhang Qiang, Sun Jie, Zhang Weidong, Yue Yang. Co-executive producers, Cary Cheng, Zhao Haicheng.
Crew
Directed, written by Ding Sheng. Camera (color, widescreen, HD), Ding Yu; editor, Ding; music, Lao Zai; production designer, Feng Ligang; costume designer, Wang Yi; sound (Dolby Atmos), Chen Chen; special effects supervisor, Sam Wang; special effects, Daysview Digital Image; visual effects supervisor, Huang Jianmin; visual effects, China Film Studio Post-production Co.; 3D visual effects, Chuck Comisky; action director, Han Guanhuan; stunt coordinators, He Jun, JC Stuntmen; associate producers, Howard Chen, Ji Xiang, Chen Fei, Lin Shulong, Li Gang, Xu Yang, Chen Lulu; assistant director, Zou Yizheng; casting, Li Haibin, Gan Di.
With
Jackie Chan, Liu Ye, Jing Tian, Yin Tao, Guli Nazha, Na Wei, Liu Yiwei, Liu Hailong, Zhou Xiao’ou, Yu Rongguang, Wu Yue, Liu Peiqi. (Mandarin dialogue)
