Howdy
I have read in the intrnet …the Traditionnal WC of GM William Cheung have some Hung Yi fa WC …Does Gm Cheung learned the yip man system and the Hung yi fa WC???
I ask the questions since the system of GM Cheung look different of the others Yip Man WC ...
Does right or just bull****…
Steeve
Well, then, it’s obviously indisputable :rolleyes:
Both camps have discounted this possibility - if you searched back through historical threads you’ll find more information (and disinformation) about this and related subjects than any sane person would want to know.
You probably ought to do a bit more research than risk raising a subject that would lead to YAFW (yet another flame war) - unless of course that was your intention. 
No its not my intention…I just ask
Hey Steeeve,
Do you practice wing chun? What school? I’m in Ottawa as well. So just wanted to say hey.
J
Hey Jeff
No I dont train WC in Ottawa …I have train it in the past…
Do U train in WC or another style ?
In Ottawa U have two choice the Sunny Tang (moy Yat) or the Fongs WC…
Steeve:)
Steeeve,
Ya, I train Ving Tsun with the Sunny Tang school on Richmond Rd.
I was just curious, cause I saw that your in Ottawa
J
Jeff
I know where u train …Sifu John…
When I decide to perfect or continue my training ...its the school I will go
probably the best school in Ottawa in WC…
Ur a senior student at this school right?
Steeve
Hey Steeeve,
Yup, John Peluso is my Sifu.
I wouldn’t call myself a senior though, there are guys there with probably double the time I’ve got and they can mop the floor with me. I feel really fortunate to be a part of the school and lineage. There are some really good people from the other schools that I’ve met in our lineage as well.
The way I see it, the number of years that you’ve trained are equal to your age.
6 years of training = 6 years old (I’m still a baby)
The door is open when you’re ready.
J
Steeeve, the answer to your question is no.
From HFY oral traditions, the late GM Yip Man was not part of the HFY line. You can find the HFY generation line at www.hungfakwoon.com which the HFY official website and www.vtmuseum.org which has plenty of info on HFY for you to consider in your research.
The Hung Fa Yi Wing Chun lineage and the Traditional Wing Chun lineage are two separate lineages. Many similarities and differences can be drawn from one Wing Chun lineage to the next. Enjoy your training and thanks for the question.
Savi.
Hey
First …Jeff I just visited ur school long time ago and i like it (i mean peoples and the way) sorry im french from Hull my english is bad :
For sure if I will continue my WC I go at this school…
Savi
Thank for ur response…I just ask that since I read some misinterpretation in internet …I see the WC of GM Cheung but never see the HFY just from book
My next questions is why GM Cheung is so different of the other WC ?
Some YIp man Wc have different siu nim tao ,chum kiu and biu jee …even the woodendummy are different …but Gm Cheung WC is completly different
I just ask no war here … just questions
Hello Steeeve,
Since the publishing of the book “Complete Wing Chun” most wing chun practitioners are aware of the differences and similarities between not only HFY and TWC but those of Chi Sim Weng Chun as well. The connection between the 3 have also been made by each individual lineage such as the newest one coming from Sifu Sergio Iadarola.
Dr. Leung Jan was the creator of Siu Nim Tau, Chum Kiu and Biu Tze. There is historical proof that Grand Master Leung Jan liked to simplify things. Proof of that is his creation a few years before his death of Gu Lo Wing Tjun. Again a simplification of Siu Nim Tau, Chum Kiu and Biu Tze and assimilating it in to one curriculum. The Gu Lo Wing Tjun system was so named after his native village of Gu Lo, where he spent the final years of his life after his retirement.
http://www.wingtjun.nl/index.php?page=history
Some of the answer may lie in the fact that Chi Sim, HFY and TWC were practiced before the time of the red boats and so some or all of the stories reported through these lineages may or may not influence your own perspective of how and why certain systems appear to differ on the surface.
http://www.hfy108.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=1747
For first hand experience you may want to read this thread…
originally posted by mario bava
I want to share the experience I have had so far in the Hung Fa Yi Wing Chun system. I originally have over 6 years experience in Yip Man Wing Chun, where I qualified as an instructor in May 2004. I have been training in the Hung Fa Yi Wing Chun Headquarters in America for 1 month. The experience has been very enjoyable…
http://www.hfy108.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=1196&perpage=15&pagenumber=1
Enjoy
Thank Tony
I will take a look to the links u give …
Steeve;)
Tony
I have take a look to the link
Interesting stuff …
The web site of Sergio Botzepe and the discussions forum …
Does wing chun is direct ,simple and effective…Wc like Wong shun leung,moy yat,
Duncan leung follow this simplicity…in the yip man WC
Thank to help me in my search
Whats system of WC do U practiced?
Steeve