Peace
Shaolinboxer:
I can say that the martial arts are not on a decline because I know so many good martial artists. Some are artistic, others intellectual, some are incredibly dangerous, and most are a mix.
Maoshan:
Really? What defines good to you? From my point of view:
Artistic Means: Forms. Question, can they apply it for real?
Intellectual Means: They read and theorize more than train which leads to (because of inadequate experience) passing on their substandard concepts to those that know no better and hold it up as being gospel.
Dangerous, is a matter of perception. Amongst non-martial artist this person can be dangerous. What about a peer?
This is not to say that the mix can’t exist but you say you know so many.
I know a lot of Martial Artist, but I know only few that are good which leads me back to the first question, What defines good? To you?
Shaolinboxer:
I do not believe the intensity of training has necessarily decreased.
Maoshan:
How can you say that? The average Class is at best 2x a week at 1-11/2hrs at a time. Most students put no more time into it than that. It’s hobby for most. In the past, it was a matter of life and death. Also, the teachers of the past stayed in a students behind to the point of abuse if the student didn’t put enough effort in the work entailed. Because if the student was crap they would lose face. And this is just one example.
Shaolinboxer:
We can acutally train harder now for several reasons. One is that techniques have been adapted to maintain their martial character while protecting the essential health of the practitioner
Maoshan:
What are you talking about? Who today trains as hard as the practitioners of the past? Besides anybody that really wants to learn doesn’t care about all that anyway. They just want to learn and will endure whatever to get that knowledge. And staying with this line of thought, In the Internal, the art is supposed to be tailored for the individual. In a lot of the external schools as well as Wushu and fake Internal teachers were found to be using methods that could lead to the detriment of the students health over time. But that has never happened to real teachers who learned their Art and taught/teach that way.
Shaolinboxer:
Two is that modern medicine has removed much of the fear of injury, allowing us to move away from forms if we wish and include more frequent open sparring. So things may actually balance out.
Maoshan:
Fear of injury? That’s the reason most people want to learn the Martial Arts, fear of being hurt by some aggressor. No offense, but you have some strange ideas concerning Martial Arts. What people feared getting hurt learning the Art? You learn to fight by fighting. You get better by getting hurt under controlled circumstances. Pain and the thought of pain along with experience is what raises your level of skill. Without this clear and present danger, all martial Arts would be nothing more than a dance and in fact it wouldn’t exist.
Now, What is the purpose of forms? It goes far beyond the simple catalogue of techniques strung together like pearls in a comprehensive manner.
In Ba-Gua in particular, forms train alignment in motion, moving with a root, stamina, speed, control and constant refinement through which is the only way to master the Art. Proper teaching leads to balance.
Shaolinboxer:
As society changes, so do our needs for self defense.
Maoshan:
What does this mean?
A physical attack is a physical attack. In the history of man, how has this changed? And how could it change?
Shaolinboxer:
Martial arts continues to be improved by being open, powerful, intense group and individual experience used to build the strength needed to live without violence in a violent world
Maoshan:
I disagree. It’s a known fact that the BS permeates almost all facets of this society. The real has to be seeked out. The more real the more hidden.
We are neither Taoist nor Buddhist living on top of Mt Huashan or Songshan. We live in a violent world getting more violent by the minute.
Peace is within. A saying by I believe Natural fist Master Tu Hsin Wu said “ There is no reason in the world to fight, but every reason to know how”. That was in the 1920’s. Where are we now? I understand where your coming from but it’s too idealistic. I live in the reality that is, not what I wish for.
Shaolinboxer:
It should bring all of us together, regardless of the nature of our practice, not just some of us.
Maoshan:
It’s the nature of our practice that separates us. Can the Moon Vie with the Sun? Can Flaw contend with flawless? Can you be yes and no at the same time? Actually you can, but you will lean toward more toward one or the other.
Peace
Maoshan