Count
Thanks for the info. Just as I thought that you have your reason with it. Just to clarify one more point on the postmordiol moduel Bagua. It is based on the microcosmos (humanity) and all thing concerning it. So fire is heart (more like brain) and Water is kidneys. That’s another reason why fire has to be on top (a standing person not an upside down person). Anyway, you have your reason to draft it your way. 
Mantis108
Contraria Sunt Complementa
I’m one of the people here who really studies a lot of theory. I already do acupuncture and hard tissue manipulation but I’m studying Chinese medicine to improve my martial arts. In the context of medicine knowledge is a critical component of skill, but only when grounded in physical experience.
Razak, I have respect for you and I can see that your posts are always to the point and well thought out, but at what point do you feel wisdom (which I define here as “tested” knowledge) should be incorporated into physical skills? You say you want to generate discussions about applications, but this isn’t a virtual reality board where a person can say “here feel this.” So why do you work so hard agaist the discussion of the most important aspect of the arts that can be dialogued about here, the theory?
To use the analogy of the medicine (I recall posting this same model a few months ago in the same kind of discussion), imagine three Doctors. The first doctor knows only theory, but hasn’t got any practice. The second Doctor has hands-on experience but doesn’t know the theory behind what he does. The third Doctor has a balance of theoretical training and practical experience. Who do you want be treated by? If they were martial artists who would want at your back?
I think that the “shut-up and train” attitude may be useful towards beginners, but a time comes when incorporating a couple of thousand years of pragmatic experience into your training can keep you from wasting a lot of time re-inventing the wheel.
By the way Count, until this century south was always at the top of Chinese maps. Maybe you need to look at some older Chinese maps.
“The heart of the study of boxing is to have natural instinct resemble the dragon” Wang Xiangzai
Thanks Kevin
I will remember that next time I am travling to 19th century China. Are you sure it hasn’t been more than 100 years? Bagua isn’t that old either.
theory
Kevin,
Thanks for the compliment. I have no problem with theory as long as it applicable…I guess being around Pa Kua Chang fighters that do fight and are experience has an influence on me…most of the high level internal artist talk less about theory and they are very good…the ones I’ve met that talk theory can’t fight or won’t. Now this is not a rule but just what I’ve seen … but again please don’t mind me…I’m not the “end all and be all here” but as I stated previously if I can invite this type of discussion it’s worth the pressure!!
peace kevin
Peace Razak,
I understand what you’ve seen. I have met too many people stoned-on-mystical-Qi and who blather about aspects of Chinese philosophy far removed from their understanding. However I’ve also had the good fortune to work with a couple of old Chinese guys who are clear about the philosophy while still being able to move like a beam light. I suppose that until you get a chance to touch into it your caution is well justified, so I really can’t fault your approach.
Count, next time you are there will you pick me up a sword? They just don’t make them like they used to. (BTW the model you drew is very similar to something about 800 years old, neo-Confucians… go figure).
Well met friends.
“The heart of the study of boxing is to have natural instinct resemble the dragon” Wang Xiangzai
Applying theory to strategy
Hey guys,
Ya know, I’ve been working with Kevin’s ideas on the way the gua are constructed in relation to body mechanics. Seems like there are many, many ways to approach the action/reaction aspect of practical fighting, and I’m convinced that a serious look at applying this theory to self defense could add yet another tool to my box (so to speak).
To sight an example, I was practicing applications the other day with my friend (he’s a Yang Tai Chi stylist). I was particularly exploring possibilities for “Dragon Rises from the Water”, aka “Young Man Shoulders the Mountain”, when I energetically tried to mimic the Zhen (Thunder) Gua since Dragon is the thunder animal. It looks like this:
____ ____
____ ____
___________
Two yin lines resting on a solid yang… Which led me to take a firm root (yang line) and a soft upper body and Dan tien. This strong mental intention led to a much looser, whip like throw/takedown action. I had to firm up slightly after the first attempt, so I wouldn’t use too much Jing and hurt him. You see, I’ve spent so much time training NOT to hurt my partner, I had unconsciously been “stalling” my own power when I had applied throws and take downs at work.
The yin intention however, consciously applied, had caused me to release the tension that I held enough to send my friend spinning with enough Jing to summersault head over heels TWICE before he touched the ground! I felt like I was in a Stephen Seagal movie (sans the big ego). I’m greatful he is well trained enough to know how to fall correctly! Guess he still falls better than I throw!
So now I have successfully applied some I Ching theory, and have used it to improve my practical skills. I’d like to see if the Gua can be applied in a similar fashion to Hsing I’s five elements.
Any thoughts on this? Have any of you tried this out?
“The essence of life is struggle and it’s goal is domination. There are higher goals and deeper meanings, but they exist only within the minds of men. The reality of life is war.”
The Chart
Just to clearify, I did not follow any simaliar chart to build this. Only notes on bagua chi kung. I started with our trigrams and built it out from there. Maybe you are correct, mantis108, about humanity, (Except in the case of birth and death) so all you really need to do is print it and turn it over. You will see all the realationships are correct.
Kevin, you make a good point about the doctor but I am not positive it follows through to martial arts. How much hands on experience with no theory? How much of a balance. I gotta go with the fighter to watch my back. I will be on the lookout for 19th century swords for you. I recently found a 19th century Samuri sword at a swap meet here in LA. This old jewler pulled it out from under his desk and asked if I was interested. Sure was nice but it wasn’t my style. If anyone is interested, let me know. He only wanted $400 and I have seen simaliar for 4 times as much.
Thanks Count, I understood. I know you have your reason to do it as such. Like you indicated the directions of the Trigrams are correct.
Mantis108
Contraria Sunt Complementa