who are we?
just thought i’d throw my two cents in.
i’ve spoken to many “long distance” instructors from kempo, karate, wing chun, hsing i chuan, and more…they all are very well respected because of rank, and lineage wise. and they all told me personally that people can learn from video. if the videos are set up correctly and the student applies themselves, why not? why does it matter if the learning is in person or by video? the question is, can the instructor properly convey the information via video? and can the student comprehend it?
all of them have tests…most insist that for instructor level or black belt that the student test in person. and some of them insist the you go to their school periodically (maybe once or twice a year) for personal training/testing. and all of them insist you have a partner. how good you become is not their problem but yours! if you only play chi sao with one person, of course your results will be limited. but who really does that? and most of the time they have and insist you use correspondance with your instructor via email, telephone, occasional trips…even video confrence online.
lazy people will simply be that…too lazy to train themselves. it takes more motivation to get up and watch the video and train yourself than it does to simply go to class with everyone else. it also takes more organizational skills, especially if you start a small study group or something.
sure there is not substitute for dojo/kwoon training…and there are alot of benefits to be gained by simply practicing with other people. but that is not to say someone simply cannot learn the art from properly formatted videos. i even had one 9th dan pioneer in the okinawan martial arts tell me his long distance students actually learn and progress FASTER than his regular students because they train anytime they want to, they have the instructor at their fingertips. a kenpo instructor said the same thing publicly, sometimes the video students pick it up BETTER. they are all tested. because there are not schools in a persons area…they seem to want it more than someone who lives down the road from the school. (generally speaking that is)
the hsing i instructor told me his videos arent necessarily a home study program, but it is possible…the bottom line is this…can you pass the test?
if all of these respected masters of their various arts say it works, who are we to argue?
my thing is simply that…alot of videos are not all that INSTRUCTIONAL…but demonstrative in nature. but if the system is designed from the ground up to be instructional, step by step…i don’t see why it wouldnt work.
if these guys are willing to stake their reputations on this method…who are we to argue with them?