Anyone ever do one of these kuoshu lei tai tournaments?
Experiences thoughts?
The format is slightly kooky (you can knee, but you can’t throw inside leg kicks?) but alright. I prefer San Shou and MMA TBH.
They are a decent format, but train in the helmet first so you can get used to the lack of vision. Its the only format I have fought under that allowed shoes which is interesting I suppose.
[QUOTE=Ben Gash;1137204]The format is slightly kooky (you can knee, but you can’t throw inside leg kicks?) but alright. I prefer San Shou and MMA TBH.[/QUOTE]
Actually, unless things have changed dramatically since my involvement, you can indeed throw both inside and outside leg kicks. Although they do want to see them land at least six inches away from the knee.
I also personally worked very hard to get both elbows and knees back into the events while involved (they had once deleted them from all but world competitions) and eventually succeeded in doing just that.
My one remaining complaint had to do with the “off the platform” rule as it allows for too much “bull rushing” on the part of larger opponents.
I am also not real fond of the headcage and never have been. It makes for a constantly guarded nose and this contributes to a great deal of flailing on the part of some combatants.
Many things changed over the years. I prefer the old ways as it was more real, but I do understand the need for certain safety measures in amateur events.
I wish there was a like/thank button on this forum. Certainly both event here that I’ve taken fighters to have explicitly disallowed inside kicks.
I also don’t like the headguards (I also don’t like the San Shou chestguards), and they kinda make elbows redundant.
I wish we could get away from Lei Tai as well. The ringout rule is just silly, I’d prefer a high sided ring or a cage. One of my guys had a chest injury for months after he fell off the Lei Tai onto his opponent’s knee ![]()
The UK guys have been trying to get a pro Koushu league going, with no headguards and a ground fast wrestling rule similar to Sambo which looks pretty cool. Not sure what kind of headway they’ve made though.
I see it as an “inferior” method to Daidojuku.
[QUOTE=Ben Gash;1137211]I wish there was a like/thank button on this forum. Certainly both event here that I’ve taken fighters to have explicitly disallowed inside kicks.
I also don’t like the headguards (I also don’t like the San Shou chestguards), and they kinda make elbows redundant.
I wish we could get away from Lei Tai as well. The ringout rule is just silly, I’d prefer a high sided ring or a cage. One of my guys had a chest injury for months after he fell off the Lei Tai onto his opponent’s knee :([/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=Ben Gash;1137212]The UK guys have been trying to get a pro Koushu league going, with no headguards and a ground fast wrestling rule similar to Sambo which looks pretty cool. Not sure what kind of headway they’ve made though.[/QUOTE]
Hmm… that’s odd, Ben. I have never seen a non-standard rule set from any country. Are your Kuoshu events not affilated with I.C.K.F. or U.S.C.K.F.?
I hear you about the injuries on the platform. One of my heavyweights broke his upper humerous as a result of a 340 lb. opponent falling on him as they went off together.
Good luck on that pro league. They tried to keep me involved here with the promise of that at the end. But I was so fed up with the internal politics by that time that I just didn’t care anymore. Besides which, it never actually happened. I told the powers that be had they proposed it in the late 90’s prior to my departure, I would have made it happen for them. I always thought that with a few more rule tweaks, the venue held promise as a great spectator event.
I’m more part of the San Shou scene TBH, so I’m not sure on the Kosherness of the events (although I think one was a qualifier for the UK team) These were the rules
http://www.pro.kuoshu.co.uk/amateur_rules_p2.html
[QUOTE=Ben Gash;1137260]I’m more part of the San Shou scene TBH, so I’m not sure on the Kosherness of the events (although I think one was a qualifier for the UK team) These were the rules
http://www.pro.kuoshu.co.uk/amateur_rules_p2.html[/QUOTE]
Well, I sure do see it right there in bold at the top. I was unable to find a page on the current rule set sanctioned by the parent organization (which I see has changed its name once again).
But if this is a new change, it’s not a good one. Oh well.. I don’t really keep pace with what they do anymore. Six years of warring with them to change the rules back to what it used to be just plum wore me out. And I was only partially successful at that.
It’s an okay structure, but they really need to look at changing with the times and this is something they have never been real keen on doing. :rolleyes:
So the San Shou Federation is still using chest protectors, eh? What kind of gloves are now being employed if I may ask?
[QUOTE=Mike Patterson;1137224] One of my heavyweights broke his upper humerous as a result of a 340 lb. opponent falling on him as they went off together.[/QUOTE]
One of my guys got punched on the head. He was so mad and grabbed his opponent and both fell off the stage with his body weight on top of his opponent. His opponent’s head shot didn’t end the fight but his body smashing did. The body smashing is a dirty trick. You pretend that you lose balance. The truth is you do it on purpose. The height of the stage will be an excellent place to play that trick. You may not get any point by doing so, but if your opponent can’t continue after that, that’s all you need. In the ring or cage, you won’t have that “Lei Tai height” advantage.
I think it’s 12oz over 80kg and 10oz under (for some reason google docs won’t load the rules at the moment).
[QUOTE=YouKnowWho;1137265]The body smashing is a dirty trick. You pretend that you lose balance. The truth is you do it on purpose. The height of the stage will be an excellent place to play that trick. You may not get any point by doing so, but if your opponent can’t continue after that, that’s all you need. In the ring or cage, you won’t have that “Lei Tai height” advantage.[/QUOTE]
You are 100% correct about that. We’ve had it done to us and on occasion used it on others that “bullrush” in attempts to just push us off the platform. It’s yet another reason that the platform should be abandoned and the scoring rule along with.
[QUOTE=Ben Gash;1137268]I think it’s 12oz over 80kg and 10oz under (for some reason google docs won’t load the rules at the moment).[/QUOTE]
Yeah. Same as before I think. It’s the primary reason I passed on the Sanshou Federation back in those days. The heavy gloves plus chest protector negated body impacts entirely too much for my tastes.
when we did the AAU tournament, some years back, Javonne Holmes (sp?) did a great hip throw to a guy who bull rushed him, the guy went right off the stage. (moved him right up to the edge where he pivoted and executed a perfect throw) Unfortunately, Holmes gassed in the later round, but he fought really well up till then. I for one, was really impressed with his skill.
Get Rid of the Platform?
I hear many people that do not like the platform and the “PUSH OFF” rule. We always have fought on Wrestling mats, but with the same Push Off rule.
What are some suggestions to modify this? We always trained specifically for push off rules with anti bullrush techniques and such. Should we bring it down and fight only on mats? Should we modify the push out rule, an example would be:
Pushing out gives you nothing, however lift and throwing someone out gives you extra points and opponent can not be thrown out more than once.
any thoughts?
ginosifu
I like the leitai for the following reasons:
- It limits running to a point,
- It teaches you how to corner your opponent,
- It is cheaper to build than a ring with ropes.
I don’t like current leitai or leitai rules for the following reasons:
- I think obtaining points by pushing someone off the platform is lame. Though causing them to run off should earn you a point.
- The leitais that I have seen are far too big. My students are forced to fight on a six foot square leitai. There is no choice but standing and fighting, dodging, or circling. Even ten foot platforms would reduce “running” time.
- More probability of injury from falling rather than fighting.
The concept of fighting of a raised platform to enhance the danger of the competition is passe in our modern liberal, litigious societies.
[QUOTE=sanjuro_ronin;1137221]I see it as an “inferior” method to Daidojuku.[/QUOTE]
What is that?
[QUOTE=mooyingmantis;1137453]I like the leitai for the following reasons:
- It limits running to a point,
- It teaches you how to corner your opponent,
- It is cheaper to build than a ring with ropes.
I don’t like current leitai or leitai rules for the following reasons:
- I think obtaining points by pushing someone off the platform is lame. Though causing them to run off should earn you a point.
- The leitais that I have seen are far too big. My students are forced to fight on a six foot square leitai. There is no choice but standing and fighting, dodging, or circling. Even ten foot platforms would reduce “running” time.
- More probability of injury from falling rather than fighting.
The concept of fighting of a raised platform to enhance the danger of the competition is passe in our modern liberal, litigious societies.[/QUOTE]
Do you think if we apply this type of rule set but on a wrestling mat, would it have Lei Tai “Feel” to it? What if we were to get rid of the “Push Out” rule in favor of a smaller ring size such as a 8’ - 10’ ring and apply the no running out rule?
ginosifu
-
elevate the platform 4-6 inches. It doesn’t have to be high enough to cause injury.
-
Eliminate points for pushing, and make it so if you are kicked, punched, or thrown with a legitimate technique off the platform, that’s it. You lose.
Been following this topic with some interest because I fought “leitai” last year and won and, yes, I made liberal use of the push-out rule and, also yes, I felt like it was kind of cheesy but if those are the rules and you notice the other guy is like 2 inches from the edge, you’d be a fool not to go ahead and push him out.
OTOH…
The arguments on this thread are kind of inconsistent. We all agree that winning for a lot of just shoving a guy back feels silly but has anyone looked at the internal assumptions on why we feel it’s silly? No one has explicitly stated it but I assume the argument is that just shoving a guy back a couple feet doesn’t really do any damage and should therefore not be awarded in a fight sport.
Ok. Let’s accept the premise that only techniques that could hypothetically hurt a guy get points.
Then what do I do with these points here:
[QUOTE=Ben Gash;1137211] …One of my guys had a chest injury for months after he fell off the Lei Tai onto his opponent’s knee :([/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=Mike Patterson;1137224]
I hear you about the injuries on the platform. One of my heavyweights broke his upper humerous as a result of a 340 lb. opponent falling on him as they went off together…[/QUOTE]
So we somehow feel that simply pushing a guy out of the ring is an invalid technique because it does not represent “fighting” or “combat” and at the same time feel that we should do away with the platform because being pushed off it is dangerous? ![]()
It’s kind of interesting how leitai fights add support of the good old fashioned Taiji “push” as a valid technique. In a real fight, while there isn’t typically a raised platform, there’s certainly chairs and traffic and so on. Also, I don’t really care about people trying to bullrush me off the stage or out of the ring. If that is an issue then you really need to work on your footwork. At least one of my “push outs” was a taiji throw I did as a counter to a bullrush.