Is taiji too relaxed ...

for combat? Do you find it a disadvantage to “borrow” energy from your opponant then to merely steal it?

nah, we borrow energy and give it back to them with interest.

In theory or in practice? The reason I ask, is because all the taiji I see is, “relax, relax, relax.” But when being pushed, if tottaly relaxed, the other gets thrown against the wall. But if tight, then you’re going Hung Quan. I believe in soft, but somewhere must be tight. Look at the taiji itself, there is a point where the two are in direct opposition. But, just shooting the $hit as they say, grinding the ol gears of de brain.

You have tension in the body, you couldn’t stay standing or seated if you didn’t. You would melt to the ground in a pile of oozing flesh (like people in front of the television).

The idea in relaxing in t’ai chi, is to relax and release in order to move. In order to pivot, you would need to relax one of the ingrinal groove at the waist. In order to move forward you would need to relax the knee. When this type of relaxation becomes part of your cellular memory you will be able to move through a form through releasing tense areas which obviously adds tension to others. The concept is to be tense in only the areas necessary to maintain and execute the movement. Using only the energy necessary to accomplish the task and nothing more.

you use muscles to move no matter what. you don’t use your muscles to generate power. also if you’re worried about being sent into a wall then you’re not yielding

I guess both in theory and in practice. You need to relax, but not too relaxed that you completely collapse on the floor. Also, Yan Gao Fei can stand perfectly relaxed in a high horse stance (with legs slightly bent and with no obvious brace of the leg) and have someone try to push him while he remains unmoving. If he chooses, he can probably bounce him away too.

I think there is a basic terminolgy problem here that underlies many misconseptions about tai ji. I will even go so far as to say that tai ji has easily become the single most misunderstood and abused among the nei jia arts.

The quality that should be maintained while practicing tai ji, or any nei jia art for that matter, is romanized as song, or sung. There is no direct translation in the english language, but the single word that comes closest is relaxed.

I agree with some the the points made by Nexus, “relax and release in order to move” to a point, but there is more to it than that. There is a “lively” or “energetic” quality contained in the meaning of song that is not contained in the common understaning of “relaxed.”

As to the use of muscles for movement, “you use muscles to move no matter what. you don’t use your muscles to generate power.”, I think something is missing here too. While muscles are, obviously, used in tai ji movement, the question is, which muscles? It is not the same muscles used in most common movement. There is greater reliance on the lower body, including the legs (obviously), the pelvic and postural muscles (luo kwa and spinal regions) and most importantly a co-ordination and intergration of movement while maintaining critical alignements that is generally not achievable without consistent and proper practice under the guidance of someone already capable of this movement. All of this while maintitaining the quality of song, oh btw did I mention proper breathing? ;->

I haven’t posted in a while, although I have been reading everything, because I am frustrated at the limited ability to communicate these types of concepts (regarding neijia skills) through words. Any ways, these are my thoughts.
Good training,
Walter

umm yeah romanization a lot of things get lost. i know the chinese so yay haha. anyways even though when romanized it can’t be completely expressed through words there’s still practise which is the most important thing of all.