I read a book by Masaaki Hatsumi, Ninja Grandmaster, abd the book featured an interview in one of its chapters. The interviewer was a martial artist from India who studied with Hatsumi for the short time he was visiting Japan.
They got into a discussion about sport vs real training. The Indian student said this: “There are many wrestlers in India and it is very popular in the cities. But even the wrestlers will not venture to the country side for fear of the deadly martial artists that live there. One particular martial artist walks 10 miles a day, barefoot, while tending his sheep. He is nimble in the feet and has a scariness about him that no wrestler would want to face.”
Hatsumi responds: “I am glad that you recognize the difference between sport and real life training.”
My analysis:
These deadly countryside martial artists are the one’s who are actually hiding from the city and from being challenged. Who is going to roam around the jungle looking for a contest? No one. So these sheep herding tough guys hide away from the city slickers while regaling the local kids with stories of the deadly ten mile walking prowess.
The training methods of wrestlers are well known And video taped. They work hard to get good at what they do. The interview made no mention about the training
Methods of these scary fighters from the countryside.
Wrestlers get involved with resistance training which is like a dirty word many tmaists. As a kid reading this for the first time I could not help but fantasize about meeting this deadly sheep herder. Then when I started resistance training, combined with YouTube, I stopped fantasizing and started actually training. There will never be videos of these so called deadly fighters because they only exist in oral legends.
A few things:
Competition STARTED with TMA and the “too deadly” still is and always will be part of sport combat arts ( every sport art has illegal moves that are too dangerous for competitions).
The notion of resistance training has ALWAYS been a part of TMA.
Those folk legends are just that legends, but what many don’t realize is the truth behind them:
Those masters that are “too deadly” for sport were the masters of those that currently DID sport, that has “retired” to the country life.
Behind every folk tale and legend is the truth, if you look hard enough.
There is an always will be a difference between sport and “real world” fighting, to say they are the same is naive at best.
The issue is that some people forget that “sport” fighting is PART of the preparation for REAL fighting.
It is not and never has been (till now) a question of either / or.
[QUOTE=sanjuro_ronin;1116153]A few things:
Competition STARTED with TMA and the “too deadly” still is and always will be part of sport combat arts ( every sport art has illegal moves that are too dangerous for competitions).
The notion of resistance training has ALWAYS been a part of TMA.
Those folk legends are just that legends, but what many don’t realize is the truth behind them:
Those masters that are “too deadly” for sport were the masters of those that currently DID sport, that has “retired” to the country life.
Behind every folk tale and legend is the truth, if you look hard enough.
There is an always will be a difference between sport and “real world” fighting, to say they are the same is naive at best.
The issue is that some people forget that “sport” fighting is PART of the preparation for REAL fighting.
It is not and never has been (till now) a question of either / or.[/QUOTE]
My issue with that chapter is that they did not outline what it takes to be a deadly countryside fighter.
Let us look at judo. Before judo came Boit jujitsu masters practiced compliant joint locks. Kano institute randori. His students came back and thrashed all the traditional deadly jujitsu fighters.
[QUOTE=Mattador;1116165]My issue with that chapter is that they did not outline what it takes to be a deadly countryside fighter.
Let us look at judo. Before judo came Boit jujitsu masters practiced compliant joint locks. Kano institute randori. His students came back and thrashed all the traditional deadly jujitsu fighters.
You bring up interesting points.[/QUOTE]
That much hyped Judo contest showed the importance of live training vs " dead" training, but Kano did NOT create that type of Randori, it existed in the two systems he trained in:
Kito-ryu and Tenjin-shinyo-ryu JJ, both TJMA.
It was not a case of TMA VS SMA, it was a case of freestyle training VS pre-arranged training.
[QUOTE=sanjuro_ronin;1116169]That much hyped Judo contest showed the importance of live training vs " dead" training, but Kano did NOT create that type of Randori, it existed in the two systems he trained in:
Kito-ryu and Tenjin-shinyo-ryu JJ, both TJMA.
It was not a case of TMA VS SMA, it was a case of freestyle training VS pre-arranged training.[/QUOTE]
Of course he did not create it. Sparring in wrestling has been done in Monglia, China, India, and anywhere else there was indigenous wrestling. What Kano brought to it was some Japanese philosophy.
[QUOTE=David Jamieson;1116176]Kano brought a sport ideology to it.[/QUOTE]
There is SOME debate about that, but I tend to agree with the view that Kano believed sport would help in the promotion of Judo but should NO be the MAIN goal of Judo.
I would also imagine that the samurai who practiced the skills that later fell under the umbrella term jujitsu trained a lot more realistically when they were actually taking part in warfare, prior to the Tokugawa era. Not that the empty-hand skills were ever the main focus of the samurai, but it would have been an important auxiliary skill just in case. I’d also assume that the original jujitsu skills were simpler and far less elaborate than the jujitsu that was mostly being taught by the late 1800s.
What Kano did with his judo was an amazing accomplishment. As some have noted on this board, pre-world war II judo contained a lot more than you see now in Olympic-style judo, including plenty of groundwork. One good book on that is Higher Judo: Groundwork by Feldenkrais, originally published around 1952. A lot of the same stuff you’ll find in BJJ which, in itself, is a modification of pre-WWII judo.
One can become a good MAist without having competed in sparring/fighting, but IMO, there is quite a difference between those who have (to some degree or other) and those who haven’t at all. Of course it’s not the same as actual combat, but it’s the closest you can safely come to it, in a controlled environment. When you’ve gotten older and no longer compete, even if that fine edge is lost, you will still carry your experiences with you.
The problem is, where is the proof that the guy in the countryside wasn’t a good fighter? To base this assumption on knowing other people’s practices, and only knowing hearsay on his, is not a compelling argument. He might’ve been more modern, in the period in which he trained with others, than the others of his time. He might’ve been a prodigy. This is always the problem with making arguments from hearsay and from unconfirmed stories and applying your own assumptions to details you normally would have to admit you don’t know.
For instance, nothing in the story ascribes it to the man in the countryside or anyone related to him, so there could be no solid ground in saying the view comes from them, or that the practices they credited were walking every day, etc. If it were from them, you can bet his name would be in the story.